Orlando City vs. Seattle Sounders: Player Grades and Man of the Match

In a match that saw Orlando City pass the ball wherever and whenever it wanted, only to squander multiple scoring chances, the Lions ultimately drew 0-0 at the Seattle Sounders. The Lions struggled to find the frame, putting only three of 13 shots on target. The old adage says “you miss 100% of the shots you don’t take,” but I would argue some of those shots just weren’t worth taking and some were flubbed so badly that I wish they weren’t taken either.

Here’s how I rated Orlando City’s individual performances at Lumen Field.

Starters

GK, Pedro Gallese, 7 — It is always great to get your first-choice goalkeeper back in the net. And you really remember how much you missed him once he’s called to action in the opening minutes. In total, Pedro made a couple saves across the course of 90 minutes and held the Sounders scoreless in a match that saw him face a 1.22 expected goals against stat line. His 30 passes only found their mark 43% of the time, which isn’t great for a team that usually depends on him to spring a counterattack. For his efforts keeping the ball out of the net and being an outlet for a drop ball to relieve the high pressure, El Pulpo was good enough, but didn’t need to be spectacular. His best save came in the first minute against Heber.

D, Rafael Santos, 6.5 — Santos was the cause of the aforementioned Gallese save in the first minute. He must have been worried about something he left on the team bus because Heber made it look like he still hadn’t gotten off of it to start the match. But perhaps that was the exact wake-up call that he needed. Santos had a decent defensive performance against the Sounders but struggled in the attack. Defensively, he recorded two tackles and a clearance while only giving up one foul. Offensively, he found himself on the ball 80 times, completing 81% of his 60 passes. He found his man with only one of his five long balls and was inaccurate on all three of his crosses. Ultimately, he defended well against those coming down his left wing. Overall, I think Santos can give himself a pat on the back as he boards the plane back to the east coast.

D, Robin Jansson, 6.5 — Sometimes we look back at the statistics from a match to try to help us remember what a player did that was notable. For Jansson, it is rare to not think of a single key moment where the Beefy Swede stepped up big for the team, but it wasn’t really required. With zero tackles or interceptions on the night, Jansson only offered a clearance, a pair of blocked shots, and a foul conceded. He completed 92% of his 39 passes, with three of five long balls also being accurate, and he also drew a yellow card on Cody Baker. The center back wasn’t the cause for a goal against or booked in the match, so that in itself is noteworthy.

D, Antonio Carlos, 7 — As the match came to a close and players began to shake hands, we saw the camera pan to Antonio Carlos sitting on the pitch with a trainer and players next to him. Hopefully, this was just the picture of a man disappointed to only draw after all his efforts and nothing more serious, but I think it was also a good depiction of what Carlos gave in the match. He used his body to block two shots and was hacked down once for a foul. The Brazilian had three clearances and won two aerial duels. With 51 touches, he passed at an 84% success across 45 attempts and was one-for-two on his long balls. Perhaps at the end of the match he was just feeling a bit tattered and torn for having gone the distance against a potent attack of Heber, Nicolas Lodeiro, Leo Chu, and Albert Rusnak.

D, Michael Halliday, 6 — The 20-year-old right back drew a tough assignment by having to keep up with Chu down the flank all night. Early on, it looked as if Chu made a meal of Mikey by drawing a penalty, but thankfully he was offside on the play. In the 48th minute, Chu created another opportunity getting behind Halliday and swinging in a dangerous cross. Aside from that, Halliday mostly held firm on the right side of the defense. With 48 touches, Halliday had one key pass in his 26 attempts (84% accuracy). He was accurate on one of three crosses, made four tackles, and added a clearance. Unfortunately, his night came to a close in the 70th minute when he pulled up mid-dribble, grabbing his hamstring in obvious pain. Hopefully, the severity of the injury won’t turn out to be too serious.

MF, Cesar Araujo, 6.5 — Only seven minutes in, we almost witnessed the spectacular. Araujo tried to channel his inner Jose Martinez from the midweek Philadelphia Union match and go full volley at the back post. For Araujo though, he realized just how rare it is for a defensive midfielder to convert on those, as his attempt hit the side netting on the wrong side of the post. For the rest of the match, Araujo was his regular workhorse self. He made a tackle, won an aerial, and intercepted the ball once, but was booked with his only foul in the match. He had 69 touches, attempted 53 passes (81% accuracy), missed both of his crossing attempts, and completed only one of his three long ball attempts. But he maintained his positioning well and Seattle created very little up the middle.

MF, Wilder Cartagena, 7.5 (MotM) — The Peruvian returned from international duty and put in a solid shift. During his absence, there was a distinct piece missing defensively in the midfield. While the statistics show he only made two tackles, won an aerial duel, and cleared once, Cartagena does so many little things off the ball that it is hard to mention them all. He subtly finds attackers like Rusnak coming through and cuts down passing lanes or offers a bit of his body to them as they try to collect a pass. While these things do not make the stat sheet, they do matter. A key pass, a dribble, and a foul conceded won’t get you in the conversation for Man of the Match alone — but 100% passing accuracy will on 41 attempts and going seven-for-seven on long balls in a crowded and talented Seattle midfield. Welcome back, Wilder Cartagena. You were missed.

MF, Ivan Angulo, 6.5 — Fresh off a loan extension, Angulo was once again lively and hoping to make an impact. He appeared to be a bit more of himself this match and perhaps understands how to handle the turf a little bit better now. His pace didn’t seem to be hampered and made good runs into the channels playing alongside Santos. He won a corner kick in the 35th minute that nearly turned into an Orlando City goal, but a great effort by Stefan Frei kept it out. Defensively, he only made two interceptions. Offensively, he made one key pass, one cross, one dribble, and passed at a 92% clip on 38 attempts.

MF, Facundo Torres, 7.5 — Facu was everywhere on the night. If he had found the net, he would be a shoo-in for Man of the Match. But ultimately, his lack of finesse left me wanting just a little bit more and while his grade ties Cartagena, I’m docking the nod at the award from him for it. In the 76th minute, he forced Frei to make a save with no chance to control the rebound, but the Lions missed a sitter off the deflection. In the 89th minute, Torres slid a shot wide of the far post. His night finished with one foul drawn, 100% completion on his two long balls, four of six on crossing accuracy, and four key passes, while distributing the ball with 79% accuracy on 39 attempts. Only one of his four shots ended up on target, and he earned himself a yellow card for something off camera in the 41st minute without committing a foul in the match.

MF, Martin Ojeda, 6 — For me, I thought Oscar Pareja couldn’t bring on Mauricio Pereyra soon enough. Ojeda was definitely on the pitch, but he wasn’t doing anything out there that made me want to see him play for a full 90 minutes. He blasted two shots, with neither on target, and was dispossessed twice. He only found himself on the ball 39 times, which is the second lowest among outfield starters. He passed 22 times at a 68% accuracy, with one key pass. Only two of eight crosses were successful, however, his saving grace might be that he was four-for-four on his long ball attempts. I’m still not seeing a great return on investment for Orlando’s latest Designated Player, but I’m willing to be patient. I just think he needs to earn his starting minutes still.

F, Duncan McGuire, 7 — The MAC Hermann Trophy winner continues to be the spark the club needs in the attack. He has great holdup play and can create chances for himself. His imposing size allows him to win balls in the air. This was once again proven in the 35th minute as he put a header on target in the bottom left corner. A great save by Frei is the only thing that kept McGuire off of the scoresheet. Frei made a save on another McGuire header in the 65th minute before he made way for Ramiro Enrique in the 70th minute. Duncan found himself on the ball 24 times, won two aerial duels, put both his shots on target, and attempted 11 passes at a 63% completion rate. He also offered a tackle, two clearances, and two fouls conceded.

Substitutes

MF, Mauricio Pereyra (57′), 6.5 — Brought on to maestro the midfield where Ojeda left the team lacking, Pereyra was eventually able to create some dangerous chances with his pinpoint passing. His vision and quality were on full display as he split the back line in the 89th minute to give Torres a free chance at goal. Torres ultimately pushed the shot wide, which seemed only fair after Pereyra missed his own tap-in that Facu created in the 76th minute. Pereyra had 34 touches (only five fewer than Ojeda) in his time on the field. He had two key passes and a badly missed shot. He passed 26 times with 80% accuracy and even added three interceptions defensively.

F, Ramiro Enrique (70′) 5.5 — There are certain truths in the world and one of them seems to be Ramiro Enrique’s lack of real impact coming off the bench. Why Kara wasn’t chosen after we saw McGuire use his body in the air to relevant success throughout the match is something I don’t understand. However, Pareja called up on the services of Enrique. For that, we witnessed 15 touches, one way-off-target shot, and a 70% passing accuracy on 10 attempts. Surprisingly, he won three aerials, so perhaps even the smaller stature Enrique has picked up a thing or two from the big men on the training ground.

D, Kyle Smith (70′) 6.5 — Brought on to replace an ailing Halliday, Smith didn’t miss a beat. He recorded 21 touches, a key pass, a dribble, a tackle, and two clearances. He completed just 61% of his 13 passes, going one-for-one on crosses and was accurate once on two attempted long balls.

MF, Felipe (83′) N/A — The changes in the 83rd minute were likely Pareja wanting to hold onto the point the Lions had earned on the road. Felipe won an aerial duel and added a tackle in his time on the pitch. He completed eight of his 10 passes but was inaccurate on his only long ball attempt.

MF, Dagur Dan Thorhallsson (83′) N/A — Dagur Dan was able to muster one shot and a tackle in his brief time on the field. Aside from that, he completed six of his eight passes.

That’s how I saw the performances in a draw against the Seattle Sounders on quick turnaround. It was great to have our Peruvians back, with one of them getting my personal Man of the Match honors. Be sure to cast your vote for this game’s Man of the Match in the poll below, and tell us your thoughts about this one down in the comments.