Orlando Pride
Orlando Pride vs. NJ/NY Gotham FC: Final Score 3-1 as Pride Fall Again in Challenge Cup Play
Two second-half goals doom the Pride as they fall at home to Gotham FC despite leading early.
The Orlando Pride (0-2-1, 1 point) fell for the second time in the 2023 NWSL Challenge Cup, losing 3-1 to NJ/NY Gotham FC (2-0-1, 7 points). Megan Montefusco gave the Pride an early lead, but a 35th-minute penalty conversion by Jenna Nighswonger sent the game into halftime at 1-1. Two goals in three minutes by McCall Zerboni and Yazmeen Ryan sealed the game for Gotham as the Pride couldn’t find a way back.
The Pride started this game without starting fullbacks Kylie Strom and Haley McCutcheon, both of whom were either ill or injured. They were also without Marta and Adriana, who are at the FIFA Women’s World Cup with Brazil. The only other change made by Seb Hines to the usual starting lineup was replacing starting striker Messiah Bright with Ally Watt.
The back line in front of Anna Moorhouse consisted of Celia, Emily Madril, Montefusco, and Brianna Martinez. Vivana Villacorta, Mikayla Cluff, and Jordyn Listro were in the midfield and Erika Tymrak, Julie Doyle, and Watt made up the attacking line.
With Marta away on international duty, Tymrak was given the armband for the first time as a member of the Pride. It was a big moment for the veteran who grew up on the west side of the state and went to the University of Florida.
“It means a lot,” Tymrak said after the game. “Especially, you know, retiring, coming out of retirement, and being able to wear the captain’s band in my home state means a ton to me.”
It was a game of two halves, with the Pride being the better team in the first 45 minutes and Gotham controlling the second. Coming into this game last in the division, the Pride knew they needed something out of this game and they got off to a great start. But the late first-half penalty seemed to take the wind out of the team’s sails. Within the first 15 minutes of the second half, the Pride were down two goals and there didn’t appear to be a way back. Even with attacking changes, Gotham created the better opportunities and comfortably took all three points.
The Pride had the first attack of the game in the second minute. Martinez sent a long ball down the left for Watt and Gotham center back Ellie Jean got to it first. However, her touch was towards her own goal line, allowing Watt to gain possession in the box. Unfortunately, the forward had few options and a tight angle, sending the shot into the arms of Gotham goalkeeper Mandy Haught.
In the ninth minute, Martinez sent another good ball down the left for Watt. This time, the Pride forward got to it first and was fouled by Jean. Tymrak stepped up to take the set piece, sending it towards the near post where it met the head of Montefusco. The center back beat former Pride defender Ali Krieger to the ball and sent it to the far post to give the Pride a 1-0 lead.
“We’ve been working on set pieces a lot and it’s a good area to capitalize on the game,” Tymrak said about the goal. “So we have really strong players in the air and I just tried to kind of whip it in as hard as I can knowing that if someone gets a head on it, it’ll be in. And Meg did a great job hitting the near post and I’m stoked that she scored that.”
The Pride had another chance in the 17th minute when Doyle laid the ball back for Cluff at the top of the box. The midfielder attempted to curl her shot towards goal, but it was deflected by Mandy Freeman just over the crossbar.
Gotham got its first attempt of the game in the 19th minute when Nighswonger received the ball at the top of the box from Midge Purce and dribbled around Listro before taking a low shot. It was a soft effort that didn’t challenge Moorhouse, who easily collected it.
In the 28th minute, a turnover by Nealy Martin enabled Cluff to play Watt forward. Cluff made a run into the box and received the ball back, forcing Haught into a save. But the flag went up for offside on the initial ball to Watt.
Gotham nearly had a chance in the 31st minute when Purce played a great ball into the box for Katie Stengel, who split the Pride center backs. Fortunately, it was a bit too far in front of the forward and she couldn’t connect.
The visitors found their equalizer in the 36th minute from the penalty spot. Purce used some quick footwork to beat Martinez into the box and the left back slid in, taking down the attacker. Referee Shawn Tehini didn’t hesitate to point to the spot, awarding Gotham a penalty.
Purce initially stepped up to the spot, but handed it to Nighswonger when things settled down. The center back took the spot kick well, sending Moorhouse the wrong way and putting it into the corner to even the game at 1-1.
In the 43rd minute, Tymrak made a good run through the midfield and sent Watt behind the Gotham defense. In a play similar to earlier in the half, Watt shot from inside the box. Haught did well to get down and knock the ball wide with her right hand, but the assistant’s flag went up again for offside on Watt.
The Pride nearly conceded another penalty in first-half injury time when Purce took Martinez one-on-one. Martinez got a touch to the ball, but Purce regained possession and beat the left back down the end line into the box. Martinez fouled the attacker as she entered the 18, but Tehini determined that the contact occurred outside of the area.
Martinez was booked for the challenge and Nighswonger took the free kick next to the end line. It was into the mixer, but Moorhouse did well to punch it away and the Pride cleared.
At halftime, Gotham had slightly more possession (50.9%-49.1%) and better passing accuracy (80.9%-72.5%), but the Pride had more shots (5-4), corners (3-0), and crosses (5-4). Both teams put two shots on target and got one past the opposing goalkeeper.
“I think it was disappointing in the first half,” Listro said after the game. “Obviously we came out pretty strong and put them under pressure and got that early goal and, honestly, we needed to capitalize on other ones and just stay tight defensively and not turn off.”
“You never want to concede goals, but especially going into the halftime. Message was keep doing what you’re doing,” Hines said about his halftime speech. “You know, you’ve done well so far in the game. Put a lot of good pressure on, lot of turnovers, created some opportunities. We need to stay onside was one of the messages and recognize the moments where we can get closer to Gotham.”
The Pride nearly had a pair of chances in the early minutes of the second half, but couldn’t stay onside. In the 47th minute, Krieger fouled Watt, giving the Pride a free kick from about 30 yards out. Tymrak sent the ball into the box for Watt, whose touch found Doyle and the forward tapped it in. But Watt started her run a little early and was offside on the initial ball.
In the 52nd minute, Madril played a great ball forward for Martinez, sending her behind the Gotham defense. The left back was taken down inside the box by Freeman, but Martinez was offside.
Gotham took their first lead of the game in the 55th minute. Nighswonger found Zerboni near the Pride box, where the midfielder had been left open by Villacorta. The former Gotham captain attempted an ambitious shot from distance, sending a rocket past Moorhouse and in to give the visitors a 2-1 lead. Moorhouse was closer to the side where Zerboni shot and still didn’t react quickly enough to stop it.
A couple of minutes later, Gotham struck again. A give-and-go between Ryan and Zerboni allowed Ryan to split Cluff and Madril. The midfielder caught Moorhouse leaning to her right and sent inside the goalkeeper’s left post, increasing the Gotham lead to 3-1.
“We always talk about the big five and that’s five minutes after a goal is scored or five minutes after halftime and I don’t think that we were mentally prepared enough for those five minutes,” Listro said about conceding the two early second-half goals. “Because those were crucial moments in the game that we should have locked in and stayed focused.”
Gotham continued pushing in an attempt to extend its lead. In the 59th minute, Ryan took a shot from the top of the box that was blocked by Madril. The visitors retained possession and found Stengel for another shot, but this one was blocked by Martinez and into the arms of Moorhouse.
Following those opportunities, Hines made his first change of the game. Looking for some offense, Bright came on for Celia and Listro replaced the Spaniard at right back.
Gotham came close to scoring a fourth in the 64th minute when Cluff blocked Purce’s cross attempt out for a corner. Nighswonger took the set piece and nearly found the head of Zerboni, entering the six-yard box, but Bright headed it away.
That was the last action of the game for Zerboni after a goal and an assist, as she was replaced by Maitane Lopez. At the same time, Allie Long entered the game for Stengel.
The Pride made two additional changes in the 71st minute, bringing on Amanda Allen and Summer Yates for Watt and Tymrak.
It looked like the Pride had a chance in the 75th minute, when Listro sent Yates behind the Gotham defense. She initially had a breakaway, but Jean caught up and Yates’ shot was wide. The miss didn’t matter because Yates was offside.
In the 77th minute, Doyle played Bright into the Gotham box. A good first touch got her behind Krieger, but the center back did well to catch up and block Bright’s shot out for a Pride corner kick.
The ensuing set piece was punched by Haught and ended up with Allen, but her cross was cleared out by Lopez for another corner. This one found the head of Listro charging towards the back post, but it was a weak header and easily cleared.
Gotham had a good chance in the 83rd minute when Lopez sent Purce into the Pride box and the attacker found Cyera Hintzen near the top of the six-yard box. Fortunately, Hintzen didn’t fully connect with the ball, sending it wide.
In the 88th minute, the Pride appeared to have their best chance of the second half when Listro beat Nighswonger to a free ball and sent Yates behind the Gotham back line. The substitute dribbled around Haught and shot, but missed wide. After the miss, the flag went up for offside, negating the attempt.
A minute into injury time, the Pride created the game’s last chance through some quick passing between Montefusco, Cluff, and Doyle, with the final pass sending Bright through. Kristen Edmonds, who came on for Freeman in the 79th minute, caught up to the striker. She had Allen open in the middle of the box, but didn’t spot her soon enough and the eventual pass was blocked out of play.
Gotham led the full-time statistics with more possession (51.2%-48.8%), shots (14-8), and shots on target (6-2), and better passing accuracy (75%-70.8%). The Pride had more crosses (14-12) and corners (7-3), but they didn’t result in enough chances to get anything out of the game.
“Performance wasn’t good enough,” Hines said about the game. “We know we had a good start, but then it’s seeing it out throughout the whole game and, you know, Gotham took their goals well. Two goals from outside the box, but I think we will have to look at ourselves and we know that we can do much better.”
“Soccer is always a game of two halves. No two halves ever look the same,” Tymrak added. “I thought the first half we came out really strong. We kept the ball. We were sharp. We pressed them. We were organized. We were threatening. And I think there’s a point where we kind of let our foot off the gas a little bit. And then in the second half, I feel like we were just defending a lot and just couldn’t really catch that rhythm unfortunately.”
A big impact on the game was the Pride being unable to hold their runs. Watt and Yates were sent behind the Gotham defense multiple times in this game and it might’ve been a different story had they held a half-second more.
“We scored a really good goal. Great ball from Erika and a great header from Meg from a set piece. And, you know, we had a couple of more moments where we got in behind their back line and been offside. And them moments can change if we stay onside. You can score goals and then you’ve got all that momentum by scoring goals, and then, obviously, it’s offside and then you give them an opportunity to get back into the game.”
The loss sees the Pride remain in last in the East Division with only one point from their first three games. They’re now six points behind Gotham and seven points behind the North Carolina Courage, needing to finish in at least second to reach the semifinals.
Due to their two postponements against Gotham earlier this year, the Pride have played just half of their six Challenge Cup games. They still have to play each of the three teams in their division, but two of those three games are away from home.
The Pride will look to climb up the Challenge Cup standings next Saturday night when they face the Courage in North Carolina.