Orlando City vs. Charlotte FC: Five Takeaways

Orlando City has advanced to the Major League Soccer Eastern Conference semifinals for the second year in a row. It took an instant classic performance from goalkeeper Pedro Gallese in penalty kicks for Orlando City to advance 1-1 (4-1), but the good guys ultimately prevailed in a match that was an emotional rollercoaster from the jump. What follows are our five takeaways from a joyous night at Inter&Co Stadium.

Oh So Close!

First, the good news: the version of Orlando City that started Game 3 more closely resembled the same squad that earned a resounding 2-0 victory in Game 1 rather than the lackluster road squad from Game 2. The bad news, however, is that the team was unable to finish the solid chances that it was creating. At the end of the first half, Orlando held strong statistical leads in possession (60.7%-39.3%) and shots (8-3) and at a minimum should have been in the lead by a goal. Orlando came close by rattling the woodwork twice and missing a few high-quality shots in the first half. These were misses, but they were near misses.

As the match advanced, it’s understandable if fans started to fear that those early opportunities would come back to bite the team in the backside. Luckily for all Orlando City fans, the universe had other plans.  

Let’s Get Physical

In the days leading up to the match, our Mane Land staff writers spoke a lot regarding Orlando’s need to control its emotions throughout the match. Andrew DeSalvo wrote about how Wilder Cartagena had a line between aggressive and assertive that would be razor thin. Charlotte came out of the gate looking to muck up the match and played physical soccer as the visitors attempted to assert their dominance over Orlando City. That type of game plan may work for road teams who are on the ropes and are trying to get under their opponents’ skin, but in my opinion, Charlotte didn’t become one of the top defending teams in the league the whole year by specializing in extracurricular pushing and shoving.

The tough guy act resulted in six yellow cards for the opposition and seemed to have no real effect on Orlando’s disposition. I was pleased with how Orlando City players handled their emotions and played aggressively without significant eruptions which could have ended the season.

Defensive Breakdown or Lucky Break?

With a little under 10 minutes to play in regulation, Charlotte found its first goal in the series and looked to be in prime position to advance to the next round. In the 81st minute, a ball leaked over Robin Jansson, springing a Charlotte attack, and Liel Abada was able to send it to Karol Swiderski in front. The striker sent it in on net, and Gallese likely would have been in a solid position to stop the shot, but a slight deflection sent the ball into the goal. It would have been heartbreaking for the OCSC playoff run to end due to a play like that after being so sound throughout the first 260 minutes of game time between the two sides. It was the first goal the Lions had allowed in five best-of-three, first-round games since the league adopted the format.

Was it a lucky break for the opposition or a defensive lapse on the part of the hosts? Everyone will have their own opinion on it, but ultimately it did not matter due to our final two takeaways.

Cardiac Cats at the Death

Just when you think you know how a match is going to go, the soccer gods laugh. Were we foolish to doubt that with the season on the line, there would not be at least one final Cardiac Cats moment? In the waning moments of the match, Orlando turned a deflected free kick into a corner, and Luis Muriel sent the ball in toward the goal. Duncan McGuire was pulled down in the box and Orlando City was awarded the penalty. In true MLS fashion, after a lengthy delay, the referee reviewed the video of the play, and it was at that moment, that I was sure the season was over and the call would be overturned.

Again the soccer gods laughed, and the call was upheld, allowing Designated Player Facundo Torres a chance to level the match. Torres smashed a shot low and away but it was saved by Kristijan Kahlina — his third save in Orlando’s last five penalty attempts. The rebound caromed back to Orlando’s No. 10, and he calmly buried it into the net as the stadium erupted.

Penalty Kick Heroes

A week removed from a massive dud of a penalty-kick performance, Orlando City was once again faced with a chance to advance on penalty kicks. Personal feelings about the best-of-three series format aside (I hate it), Orlando would either be the team that actually won a match in the series but was eliminated, or Charlotte would be the team that didn’t win a game but advanced. Ultimately, this match came down to two amazing efforts.

The first came from Gallese, who easily earned Man of the Match and hero status for smothering each of the first two Charlotte PK attempts, diving left to deny Pep Biel and then right to stone Swiderski. That set the tone and provided much-needed breathing room. The second heroic effort came from Muriel, Kyle Smith, Torres, and Rafael Santos, who all stepped up and buried their attempts with conviction against perhaps the league’s best goalkeeper.

With McGuire not able to be selected as one of the PK takers due to the shoulder injury he sustained on the foul that helped Torres equalize, Oscar Pareja turned to two defenders in Smith and Santos, who stepped up massively and helped power Orlando City to a 1-1 (4-1) victory over the Crown.

Those are my takeaways from Orlando City’s electric and memorable Game 3 shootout victory over Charlotte FC. Thanks to the craziness that is MLS, the No. 1, 2, and 3 seeds in the Eastern Conference have all been eliminated, paving the road for Orlando City to host playoff games until the MLS Cup final for as long as the Lions stay alive. Vamos Orlando!