Orlando City vs. New York City FC: Five Takeaways

Orlando City went on the road to play soccer on a field meant for baseball and unfortunately forgot to play soccer on several occasions. The Lions were punished for that, losing 2-1. Here are my five takeaways from the match.

Lions Caught Watching the Paint Dry

Dennis Hopper’s quote from the movie Hoosiers (RIP Gene Hackman) about not getting caught watching the paint dry came to mind on both of New York City FC’s goals, as in each case the Pigeons beat the Orlando City defense to a rebound and scored from close range. Alonso Martínez raced past everyone to tap in the rebound of a shot off the post from Maxi Moralez, and then later Julián Fernández followed a Pedro Gallese save from a Martínez shot and crossed it back into the middle, where Hannes Wolf was wide open and headed it home. Watching the replays is a painful experience, because you can see the guard briefly being let down by the Orlando City defenders and then the sudden realization that they should not have done that, but it was too late. On a comically small field, constant vigilance is required, and the team in purple failed twice to stay engaged through an entire play.

Orlando City’s Depth Was as Deep as the Yankee Stadium Field Was Wide

Which is to say, not at all. The Lions were down a goal, up a man, and simply did not have any more proven attacking players to throw on the field to try to get the tying goal. In desperate need for a goal, the Lions turned to 16-year-old Gustavo Caraballo with their final substitution and did not even use all five of their allotted subs, even though they were behind. I think Caraballo played well, and has a chance to be good — and I mean really good (said in my best Ron Burgundy voice) — but the team needed more firepower in those final minutes and did not have anyone else who could have brought more than those who were on the field as the game ended. Duncan McGuire’s absence was felt in a major way during this game, especially on the late crosses and corner kicks that the Lions could not win and convert into a goal.

Designated Player Double Play

Luis Muriel had only started one MLS game since June of 2024, but he got the start against NYCFC and linked up with fellow Designated Player Marco Pašalić to score a beautiful goal to tie the game 1-1. Alex Freeman played a long ball up the sideline and Muriel beat his defender to the ball to tip it to Pašalić. The Croatian brought the ball down and attacked at full speed right down the middle of NYCFC’s defense in a 3-v-2 situation. Pašalić cut into the middle of the field, forcing Thiago Martins to stay with him and by moving Martins just enough, it allowed Pašalić to play a ball off to his right, perfectly weighted to allow Muriel to run onto it without breaking stride. The Colombian placed it into the far corner of the net. Orlando City probably should have scored more than one goal in this game, but the one goal they scored was well executed and hopefully portends more to come from the combination of Designated Players.

El Pulpo Needed to Use Those Tentacles for Catching Instead of Batting

Goalkeeper is an incredibly lonely position to play and is often one that does not receive the appreciation it deserves because of just how hard of a position it is. No other position has its mistakes as magnified as those of a goalkeeper, and unfortunately for Orlando City, Gallese made the split second decision that he would not be able to catch Martínez’s shot, so he batted it away — but not far enough away. That mistake led to the game-winning goal. The initial shot from Martínez was eminently catchable, as it was not struck well, and even though it could have been caught it, at the least itshould have been pushed wide instead of basically right down and still in front of the goal. Gallese had six saves in the game, including a fantastic stop on a Martínez shot from close range in the 49th minute, but with goalkeepers it is far more often that their mistakes are remembered than their saves, and the initial shot that turned into the second goal definitely should have been handled better.

Another Rusty Starting Defense Combination

Robin Jansson returned to the starting lineup against New York City FC, but he did not look like he was at full strength, and neither did the back line of Rafael Santos, Jansson, Rodrigo Schlegel and Freeman. Perhaps it was just the difficult nature of adjusting to a non-regulation field (FIFA recommends a field be 74 yards wide, the Pigeons claim their field is 70 yards wide — no word on if their fingers are crossed behind their back, though). The Orlando City defensive group did not look comfortable on the field in New York. The defense did not look crisp to me, with the aforementioned ball watching, the players being a step slow to close down an attacking player, and guys going to ground more often than in a usual match. The defense allowed eight shots on target, which is the same amount as the first two games combined. The group that started on Saturday is the likely starting group going forward — at least until Nico Rodriguez returns to add more attacking midfield depth that is currently being provided by Dagur Dan Thorhallsson —and now that Jansson is back in the lineup and these four have a game together under their belts, things should get better. They will need to if the team is going to get some results.

Those are my takeaways from a game that was frustrating, but predictably frustrating, considering that Orlando City’s recent road record against New York City FC is an abysmal 0-4-2. I thought there were periods of time when Orlando City looked dangerous, and even the better side, but in the end, the Lions could not take advantage of those moments and now will have to regroup before going on the road again next week.

Let us know your thoughts about the match in the comments below.