New Year, Same Coach: It’s Time to Appreciate Óscar Pareja

The clock turned to midnight and 2026 arrived one week ago, and in the first week of 2026 there has been a lot of news about coaches, as the managers who started the season at two of the most well-known soccer clubs in the world, Chelsea and Manchester United, both lost their jobs. The manager carousel has been spinning aggressively at both clubs in recent years, so it was not a huge surprise to see either departure, but as we approach the beginning of the 2026 MLS season, the news from England’s Premier League made me appreciate even more the tenure of the man in charge of Orlando City: the iconic, white-shirt-wearing Óscar Pareja, who is about to begin his seventh season in charge of the Lions.

Pareja took charge in Orlando back in 2019, and at 6.1 years as head coach, he is currently the second-longest tenured head coach in MLS, behind only Brian Schmetzer of the Seattle Sounders. The average tenure of the 28 (Atlanta has yet to hire a head coach) non-Pareja coaches in the league is 1.98 years, so Pareja, at just beyond six years in charge, has been at the club for slightly more than three times the league average, and he has been a lot more than slightly effective ever since taking the reins, as you can see from the chart below:

• * For this chart I used the result of the game at the end of regulation or extra time, I did not give a win or loss based on the result of penalty kicks, which is too bad, because Orlando City is 8-3 in shootouts since Pareja became head coach.

Pareja’s 210 games in charge of the Lions is the 15th most in league history by a head coach at a single club, and if the Colombian is still the coach after the 33rd league game this season, he will move into 10th place on that list. The points-per-match values in the chart above show why he has been in Orlando so long, as transfermarkt.com‘s tracking ranks him 30th on the all-time list in points per match among the 179 MLS coaches who have coached at least 25 games at one club. That site has Pareja at 1.60 points per match, so perhaps it is giving wins and losses instead of draws based on shootout results, or perhaps their math is just a bit off (I know a mathematics major who can help), but the main point is that since Pareja came to Orlando he has consistently been an excellent coach — among the top 20% (16.7%, if we are being specific) in league history in points per match.

One of the coaches that Pareja ranks behind on that list, funnily enough, is one Óscar Pareja from his time as the head coach of FC Dallas. Pareja coached 180 games in Dallas and earned 1.61 points per match, ranking 27th on transfermark’s list, but if Orlando City can put together another strong season in 2026, Pareja with Orlando City may jump Pareja with FC Dallas by this time next year.

That, of course, is a big if, as the 2026 roster is slowly coming into shape but still appears to be short a few players. Sean Rollins wrote earlier this week about some OCB players who might make their first-ever appearance with the senior team this season, and Gustavo Caraballo, Justin Ellis, Colin Guske, and Zakaria Taifi all could play more this season than they did in 2025, each with the idea that they could be the next Alex Freeman and go from a handful of MLS minutes in 2025 to thousands in 2026. Lightning does strike quite often in the City Beautiful, so it could happen, but it is more likely that the front office will acquire a few more seasoned professionals to fill out the roster.

Once the roster is filled out, it is likely that Pareja will do what he has done in — according to fbref.com’s tracking — 93% of his matches as head coach in Orlando by starting a back four. Three of the four spots seem set at the moment, with left back the one question mark going into training camp. It is possible that the team signs another center back, and David Brekalo continues to play as a left back or becomes a backup, but the more likely scenario is a Robin Jansson and Brekalo pairing in the middle with Freeman on the right, and Pareja oversees a training camp battle to choose a left back among several competing players.

In four of Pareja’s six seasons the club finished the season with excellent goal differentials across all competitions, finishing +15 in 2020, +14 in 2023, +17 in 2024, and +17 again in 2025. The Lions were dead even in 2021 and -2 in 2022, making the combined total for the six seasons a healthy +61. While he has played a 4-2-3-1 most often, he has adapted around the team he has every season, playing a 4-4-2 for most of 2026, for example, and so whether the front office acquires another left back, center back, or neither and goes into training camp with a bunch of young players competing to earn roster spots, Pareja has more than earned the trust of the team, front office, and fans that he will be able to take what he is given and, to turn a famous Orlando City phrase on its head, show us that Papi can do that.

Stability is an often underrated component of a team’s success, and while Orlando City’s roster will only bring back a maximum of 65% of its minutes played from last year, bringing back Pareja and his strategic planning acumen is an unquantifiable boost for the team. The best years in the club’s MLS era have been under his leadership, and while the Lions finished lower in the standings last year than in prior years, that was really more about the rest of the Eastern Conference playing well than an Orlando City regression, considering that the Lions earned the second-most MLS regular-season points in club history during the 2025 season.

Pareja’s six years of experience ranks second most in MLS and is longer than all but three coaches among the 92 professional teams in England’s top four divisions (Premier League, Championship, League One, and League Two). It is not a coincidence that the recent years have been among the team’s best with those large positive goal differentials and deep runs in the MLS playoffs and Leagues Cup.

Sustained excellence is extremely difficult in sports, and while Orlando City only has the one U.S. Open Cup in the trophy case during the Pareja era, according to fbref.com’s tracking, only five MLS clubs (LAFC, Inter Miami, the Philadelphia Union, the Seattle Sounders, and the Columbus Crew) have more wins in all competitions than Orlando City since he took over before the 2020 season.

I am not big on making new year’s resolutions, but in 2026 I resolve to show my appreciation more often for the consistent success that Pareja has brought to Orlando City.

Vamos Orlando!