Orlando City vs. Charlotte FC: Final Score 2-2 as Lions Come Back Twice to Draw 10-Man Charlotte

Orlando City finally scored more than one goal in a game, but at the expense of dreadful defending in a 2-2 road draw against 10-man Charlotte FC at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte. The hosts took the lead early through Kerwin Vargas and withstood a player being sent off late in the first half and a tying goal from Duncan McGuire, before taking a second-half lead in transition. That Brandt Bronico goal was canceled out by Facundo Torres as the Lions (4-8-6, 18 points) split the points with Charlotte (8-6-5, 29 points) despite being a man up throughout the second half and having the ball for what seemed like almost all of that time.

Orlando’s winless streak grew to five games (0-3-2) on another wasteful night in front of goal and a defensive evening to forget. The Lions had clear opportunities to prevent both goals but failed to clear a loose ball on the first and teed up the second ball trying to clear it through the leg of the opposing forward.

“Too early we go (up) with one extra player and Charlotte found a way to score a second goal in the moment that we pushed the most,” Orlando City Head Coach Oscar Pareja said after the match. “Those circumstances made us feel that getting this result at some point it’s going to help us. I think the team made a lot of efforts to win the game, but Charlotte found that second goal and it could have been worse. Humbly today we take the point. We wanted more, but we have some positive things.”

Pareja’s lineup had only one change from the group that lost 3-1 to LAFC Saturday, as Mason Stajduhar started in net behind a back line of Rafael Santos, Robin Jansson, Rodrigo Schlegel, and Dagur Dan Thorhallsson. Felipe took Cesar Araujo’s spot in the central midfield along with fellow midfielders Ivan Angulo, Nico Lodeiro, and Torres, with Luis Muriel and McGuire up top.

Orlando City made Charlotte’s offense look like Miami’s at times in the first half, letting inferior numbers get good looks at goal. Still, the first chance of the match fell Orlando’s way. Muriel did well to nick the ball in the attacking half and he played McGuire down the right channel. The big striker was at an angle, but had plenty of net to shoot at, yet he missed a few yards wide of the right post in the eight minute.

The hosts scored four minutes later on a play that should never have resulted in a goal. The Lions had plenty of numbers back as Liel Abada took a heavy touch past Jansson down the right channel. Jansson couldn’t handle Abada’s pace and the Charlotte attacker got to the ball first. The Swede tried to block the cutback cross, but it got through. Two Lions were converging on the ball and Angulo swung and completely missed the ball, allowing it to get through. Thorhallsson initially had good coverage on Vargas but got caught ball watching when the winger peeled back to the ball. Angulo’s whiff — possibly thrown off by Felipe’s sliding arrival — and the open space gave Vargas an easy finish to make it 1-0 in the 12th minute. It was Charlotte’s first goal inside the first half hour of a game all season.

On a play indicative of the form Orlando City has been in, Torres took a pass at the top of the 18 in the 15th minute and it just…rolled off his foot. Whether he was caught between passing and shooting, only he knows for sure, but it was a weird play.

Jere Uronen then cut inside from his fullback spot and nearly doubled the lead. Left completely alone, the Finn smashed a shot off the crossbar from long range.

Orlando finally got a shot on frame in the 19th minute when Torres got his head to a high cross and nodded toward goal. It was an accurate shot, but there was little pace on the ball, allowing Kristijan Kahlina to make the save.

Seconds later, Scott Arfield blasted a shot wide from distance with Orlando outnumbering the Charlotte attackers, 6-3 in the final third.

Torres got another look in the 33rd minute but his shot was partially deflected and went straight at Kahlina.

The Lions went up a man moments later. Arfield slid in from behind and caught Felipe on a rough challenge and was initially booked. Allen Chapman went to the monitor while Felipe received treatment and the referee changed the yellow to red, putting the hosts down a player. Felipe was struggling and had to be replaced by Araujo.

The sending off didn’t immediately help the offense, which moved the ball too deliberately over the remainder of the half. Muriel tried a couple of long-range shots. The first was saved by Kahlina at the near post. Adilson Malanda blocked the second with his face and needed treatment, staying off the pitch for the final seconds of the half.

Up two men and with time winding down, Orlando sat on the ball out wide and Chapman blew the halftime whistle.

Orlando City held the halftime advantage in possession (53.9%-46.1%), shots (8-5), corners (1-0), and passing accuracy (93.4%-84.5%), with each team getting three shots on frame.

Martin Ojeda entered for Thorhallsson at halftime and the Lions changed shape to a 3-5-2. For a couple of minutes, the shape change helped.

Torres forced Kahlina to make a good save seconds after the restart. Santos then sent a shot from outside the box high over the bar moments later.

Over the next few minutes, Orlando was careless with the ball, allowing Charlotte to get forward on the counter. Torres was forced to take a tactical yellow card to break up a 2-v-1 created when Jansson gambled and lost in the attacking half in the 50th minute. Stajduhar made a huge save from point-blank range a minute later on the ensuing set piece when it deflected out to Abada. Djibril Diani then sent a header just wide of the top left corner on the corner kick.

Lodeiro put a cross in front for McGuire in the 53rd minute, but the striker sent it wide again. Muriel then had a shot blocked in the 56th as the Lions kept probing.

Orlando gave up another transition chance in the 59th minute after telegraphing a pass at the top of the penalty area. Charlotte broke with speed and Abada cut inside and shot. Jansson blocked it and it went just wide of the right post.

The Lions finally got on the board in the 63rd minute. The play started on the right side of the area with Angulo giving the ball to Muriel at the top of the 18. Muriel did well to spot Torres on the left and delivered a good aerial ball. Torres got under it and headed across the six for McGuire to run onto. The striker flicked it with a deft touch to guide it inside the right post, making it 1-1.

“I saw Facu was in a good spot to head it back and there was a little bit of space front post,” McGuire said about the play that led to his team-leading sixth goal of the year. “So, I had to make myself available and Facu put it right where I needed it to be, and luckily I got it across the goalie back post, so it was a good team goal.”

The Lions hunted for a go-ahead goal but couldn’t quite pull it off. Muriel’s shot was deflected onto the roof of the net for a corner in the 66th minute. Ojeda should have done better with a wide-open header on a good cross from Angulo in the 75th minute but steered his shot well over the bar.

The Lions paid for those near misses in the 77th minute. Orlando was in good position to thwart a counterattack when Jansson got caught on the wrong side of Patrick Agyemang. Santos was there to help but tried to clear the ball away but could only knock it back to Agyemang, allowing a sudden 2-v-1. Stajduhar came off his line but was a little late and Jansson couldn’t get back to the left in time either. Bronico chipped Stajduhar to make it 2-1. It was just the low-scoring midfielder’s seventh career goal in seven MLS seasons.

“In the 50-50 challenges, maybe they’d get the better of the challenges for the most part and they made the most of those opportunities,” McGuire said. “So, I think maybe we need to do a better job at winning the first balls, and being on the second balls, and maybe stopping the counterattack with a tactical foul a little bit more. But that’s what I think they did well.”

“We lost those two duels there, and then they found a way to hurt us,” Pareja said. “We should have been better on controlling (transitions) for sure.”

Orlando pushed forward again and created some looks in the 80th minute. McGuire’s flicked header wasn’t enough to steer a good cross on frame and on the recycle, Ojeda missed the net just wide on a partially deflected shot. On the ensuing corner, the ball fell to Torres on the left. Rather than shoot, Torres centered it for Jansson, who saw his point-blank effort saved by Kahlina, who knocked it over the goal.

Torres tied the game on the following corner kick. Lodeiro, who finished with a game-high 10 chances created, sent the ball into the box and it fell amid the bodies to Torres on the right. The Uruguayan took a touch to settle it and sent a shot through traffic and in to make it 2-2 in the 81st minute. For Torres, it was his third goal of the year and Lodeiro picked up his sixth assist.

Ojeda put a shot just over the bar and onto the roof of the net a minute after Torres equalized. Jack Lynn then subbed on for Muriel moments later. Torres sent a good cross in but Malanda knocked it behind for a corner. The set piece fell to Schlegel who sent a shot that Kahlina pushed off the post.

Two minutes later, a fantastic ball unlocked the defense and sent Lynn down the left channel behind the back line. The young striker, however, slowed up when he got the ball and Malanda caught up to him, forcing him wide, where he shot into the outside netting. Lodeiro then tried to pick out Lynn in the box in the 86th minute but may have been better off shooting from the top of the area without a defender near him.

Jansson’s flick on a set piece was wide of the back post in stoppage time and that was that.

Orlando finished with the advantage in possession (60.6%-39.4%), shots (24-11), shots on target (8-5), corners (11-3), and passing accuracy (92.8%-79.7%), but simply wasn’t sharp enough again offensively and added a leaky defense to the proceedings.

“I think we’re all disappointed with the tie, given that they were down to 10 men very early,” McGuire said. “We had our chances. I definitely had my chances. I missed two I think I should have scored. We were attacking a lot and we think we definitely should have won the game, and we’re very disappointed in ourselves, but we’re going to have to take that one point on the road and take it home to Chicago on Saturday.”

The Lions are back home with another quick turnaround when they host the Chicago Fire at 7:30 p.m. on Saturday at Inter&Co Stadium.