Orlando City vs. Cruz Azul, Leagues Cup: Final Score 0-0 as Lions Crash Out of Leagues Cup on First Ever Shootout Loss

Orlando City kept its unbeaten streak alive but lost its first-ever penalty shootout after a 0-0 draw against Cruz Azul at Inter&Co Stadium in the Leagues Cup round of 32. Stretching the team’s unbeaten run to eight matches in all competitions (5-0-3) will be of little consolation to the club after losing 5-4 in penalties to a solid Liga MX side. It was Cruz Azul’s fourth 0-0 draw in the last two Leagues Cup runs and second this year.

However, as good as La Máquina was defensively in this game, it was Orlando City’s lack of finishing that cost the team the game. The Lions lacked the finishing lethality they’ve shown for much of the team’s unbeaten run, either missing just wide or hitting balls straight at the goalkeeper.

“I thought the boys performed really well,” Orlando City Head Coach Oscar Pareja said after the match. “I think we played against a very good team that brought a very good match as well. They were intense from the first minute and the level of the technical part and the level of the tactics were first level and we were up to it. We leave the competition without losing and that’s the pain that we have. And obviously we’re sad but we played very well and I saw that Orlando City that we want to see. We’re sad but we’re proud.”

Pareja’s lineup had only one change from the squad that drew Atletico San Luis a week ago. With Kyle Smith suspended for his red card, Rafael Santos got the start. Goalkeeper Pedro Gallese started behind a back line of Santos, Robin Jansson, David Brekalo, and Dagur Dan Thorhallsson. Cesar Araujo and Wilder Cartagena started in the central midfield behind an attacking line of Ivan Angulo, Martin Ojeda, and Facundo Torres with Ramiro Enrique up top.

The first half offered few chances for either side in a physical matchup, but most of those created were by the Lions.

Orlando City should have scored early. A nice play by Angulo on the left allowed him to escape pressure and cut across the middle of the field, where he played a perfect ball to Thorhallsson on the right and continued his run. Thorhallsson gave him a perfect return pass with an open net in front of him but Angulo missed badly to the right of goal in the second minute.

Ojeda’s cross picked out Torres in front in the 10th minute but the Uruguayan got under his volley attempt and fired over the bar.

Ojeda thought he’s scored a minute later but the whistle had gone for a foul on Enrique against Cruz Azul goalkeeper Kevin Mier, who just beat him to the ball.

The visitors got their first shot in the 19th minute on a blast outside the box by Carlos Rotondi, but Thorhallsson did well to get in front of him and block it. Two minutes later, Giorgos Giakoumakis was left alone at the penalty spot and volleyed a shot off a cross from the right, but he didn’t get all of it and it was an easy save for Gallese.

Santos fired a shot high over the net in the 38th minute off a corner kick clearance and hit the Heineken sign on the facing of the upper deck.

In the 40th minute, Enrique got an excellent opportunity on the right, but he hit his shot right at Mier, who still had to make a good reaction save to keep it out.

After a couple of long-range shots by Cruz Azul that didn’t trouble Gallese’s goal, Thorhallsson got a chance from the right in the 44th minute, but he too hit his shot right at the goalkeeper. The Icelandic fullback then made a major mistake deep in first-half stoppage time, making a poor back pass straight to Giakoumakis, but the former Atlanta United striker sent his curling shot from the top of the area wide of the right post.

That was the last look of the half and the teams went into the break scoreless.

At the break, the visitors had the advantage in possession (54.1%-45.9%), shots (6-5), shots on target (3-2), and passing accuracy (88.9%-85.4%), while the Lions earned more corners (2-0) and created the most clear-cut opportunities.

The first chance of the second half fell Cruz Azul’s way when Brekalo was called for a foul and booked just after the restart. Ignacio Rivero went from goal on the free kick but Gallese punched it away.

Torres took Orlando’s first shot of the second period in the 50th minute from outside the area but hit his shot over the bar. Orlando City then squandered another great opportunity four minutes later. Angulo did well in the corner to shake free and get around the defense and into the box on the left. He picked out Enrique with a pass but the Argentine sent his left-footed effort wide of the left post from close range.

“I thought we created some (options) in very dangerous positions and you have to find the game as you see it, and we were not sharp in that finishing,” Pareja said. “But we had the best of the options and probably the best of the soccer.”

After Rotondi sent a shot well off target from the top of the box in Orlando’s defensive end, the Lions again wasted a good opportunity in the 59th minute. Enrique made a great tackle in the attacking third to win the ball, then quickly found Torres in the box. Torres’ first shot was blocked by the defense but he got in behind, still with the ball at his feet, but he sent his shot just inches wide of the left post.

Uriel Antuna tried a weak backheel flick from the top of the box in the 70th minute but it was no trouble for Gallese.

Ojeda had a go from the top of the area at the other end in the 73rd minute, but once again the shot was straight at the goalkeeper. Six minutes later, it was second-half substitute Duncan McGuire firing straight at Mier.

The final 11 minutes plus stoppage time were largely uneventful except a late chance deep in stoppage time for Cruz Azul that resulted in a Gallese save that ultimately didn’t count because the flag came up. That was the last action and the match ended in a 0-0 draw.

Cruz Azul finished with the edge in possession (54.6%-45.4%), shots (14-11), shots on target (6-4), and passing accuracy (87.3%-83.7%), while the Lions won more corners (4-0).

To determine which team would advance, there was no extra time, as the competition calls for penalty kicks immediately following a draw.

Jansson was the surprising choice to take the first penalty, and it looked like a poor decision when the defender’s shot was saved by Mier. However, Cruz Azul starting striker Ignacio Rivero missed the net wide to the right, offering the Lions a reprieve. The next eight shooters all found the mark in succession — second-half subs Nico Lodeiro, Luis Muriel, and McGuire, along with Torres for Orlando, and Andres Montano, Willer Ditta, Gonzalo Piovi, and Angel Sepulveda for Cruz Azul — sending the shootout to sudden death.

Thorhallsson was Orlando’s sixth shooter, but saw his penalty saved, putting the pressure on Gallese to make a save to keep his team in it. However, former LAFC winger Antuna scored to end the Lions’ perfect shootout record and knock Orlando City out of the competition.

“We’ve been doing good for a long period now here and we’re going to try to continue to build on that,” Jansson said. “I think today we had a great game and Pedro had some good saves too, when they had a couple of chances. I don’t think they had too many chances though. We take that with us that we had a great game, but right now we’re disappointed. We really wanted to go through, but the PKs sometimes it’s a lottery. Today we weren’t good enough. I missed and I’m not happy with that but sometimes that’s the game.”

With the Leagues Cup behind them, the Lions will have to wait until Aug. 24 to play their next game. That match will be at Sporting Kansas City.