Orlando City vs. Toronto FC: Five Takeaways

The Lions got into the win column to even their record at 1-1-0 to close out the two-game, seasoning-opening homestand that MLS put on their schedule. Orlando City’s second game of the season started out a bit boring but morphed into a thrilling 4-2 victory over Toronto FC over the course of the final 60 minutes.

What follows are my five takeaways from Orlando City’s first win of 2025.

Another Surprise Lineup Shuffle

Given the availability report had no surprises on it in the leadup to the match, Saturday’s short-term contract signings of Gustavo Caraballo, Colin Guske, and Zakaria Taifi were a clue that something wasn’t going to plan. That turned out to be the case, as David Brekalo and Nico Rodriguez each picked up knocks in training late in the week. With Orlando City’s depth issues on the back line, Oscar Pareja shuffled the deck and moved Kyle Smith to center back alongside Rodrigo Schlegel, with Smith playing on the left in Robin Jansson’s normal spot and Schlegel returning to his favored right side. That explained the signing of Taifi for depth, as the young defender has played both fullback and center back with OCB. There was another change to the back line that we’ll get to in a minute.

Overall, the Lions’ defense did well to limit Toronto’s chances. There was nothing clear cut in the first half, although there were a few dangerous passes played across the box from Federico Bernadeschi’s side. The Reds were only able to create minimal danger on shots from distance until a late set piece and a second ball situation even later in the match, but by that time the offense had put multiple goals on the board.

Freeman’s First Start a Success

The other change to the back line included the insertion of Homegrown right back Alex Freeman in the starting lineup in place of Dagur Dan Thorhallsson. While the Icelandic international didn’t play particularly poorly in the opener, Freeman’s play — including against Philadelphia off the bench — has been demanding more minutes. He got them, as Pareja needed Thorhallsson to be an available midfield depth player with Rodriguez out.

Freeman had a sensational first MLS start. Not only did he hold up well defensively on Orlando’s right side, but he showed what he can bring to the offense, scoring the second goal just moments after Cesar Araujo’s wondergoal on a free kick. Somehow Toronto’s defense got out of shape by moving too high, leaving winger Markus Cimermancic isolated on the young fullback. Orlando recovered the ball, and Eduard Atuesta dropped a pass to Smith, who moved right and launched a long ball for Freeman. The Homegrown defender stayed onside, showed his strength to get goalside of Cimermancic, and did well with a great first touch off his thigh, using his speed to break in alone on Sean Johnson’s goal. Moving the ball onto his left foot, he powered a shot toward the left post that was too hot for Johnson to handle. That quick second strike was a stunner from which Toronto never was able to recover.

Pasalic Marked Out

After a good night in his MLS debut, Designated Player Marco Pasalic was ineffective against a Toronto side that opted to surround him every time he touched the ball. Pasalic attempted no shots and created no chances during his second start. Toronto, and perhaps the inexperience of working with Freeman on that side limited Pasalic’s touches. He completed just 12 of his 18 passes (66.7%). That’s not to say he didn’t contribute. It was a foul drawn by Pasalic that set up Araujo’s opening goal.

With the Reds swarming him, the Croatian often had little choice but to drop the ball deeper or try more difficult ways to get through, which led to a few giveaways. It was a solid game plan by Toronto FC, and it’s one that Pasalic must adjust to in order to find success in MLS. Pasalic was replaced in the 65th minute by Luis Muriel, which turned out to be a good substitution.

Ojeda’s Emotional Moment

Attacking midfielder Martin Ojeda made it two goal contributions in two matches with his first goal of the season in the 63rd minute. Schlegel stabbed away an attempted Toronto entry ball to Araujo, who turned and headed straight up the field. He spotted Ojeda sneaking in behind midfielder Deybi Flores and between the two Toronto center backs, delivering a perfectly weighted ball for Ojeda to take in stride. Using a burst of speed to clear the back line, Ojeda approached goal, waited for Johnson to commit, then calmly slotted the ball into the empty net with his weaker right foot to make it 3-0. The Lions’ third goal was obviously an emotional one for Ojeda. Once the initial excitement of the goal wore off, Ojeda lifted his jersey to show he was wearing a t-shirt underneath with a picture of his grandmother, who passed away last week, with a caption reading “Siempre en nuestros corazones” (“always in our hearts”). He had tears in his eyes as his fellow Argentines Schlegel and Ramiro Enrique embraced him at midfield before the restart.

Hail Cesar!

It was an unusually bright offensive night for the Lions’ physical central midfielder. The assist on Ojeda’s goal all but put the match out of reach with half an hour to play, but the Uruguayan also got the scoring started in the 33rd minute. With Ojeda, Pasalic, and Atuesta on the pitch, it was strange to see Araujo and Rafael Santos standing over the ball to await the referee’s whistle after Pasalic had drawn a free kick just outside the penalty area. When the whistle blew, it was Araujo — the less likely of the two — who took it, blasting a shot over the wall, off the left post, and in. It was a free kick goal worthy of anything we’ve seen from notable departed set piece takers Nico Lodeiro and Facundo Torres. Aside from his two goal contributions, Araujo passed at a team-high rate of 96.3% over the course of his full 90 minutes. He also recorded an interception, did not commit a foul or pick up a yellow card, and drew two fouls on the opposition.

Bonus Sixth Takeaway: Instant Impact Off the Bench

While most of the substitutes off the bench against the Union were not terribly effective — except Freeman — Pareja’s subs made an impact against Toronto, helping see out the game. Muriel completed 85.7% of his passes, but his biggest contribution came just moments after Thorhallsson replaced Ojeda in the 80th minute. Muriel took a pass from Schlegel in his own defensive third, then made a hard turn inside to lose Theo Corbeanu, delivering a pass to Enrique at the top of the attacking third. Enrique found space, turned and gave the ball back to the onrushing Muriel, who drew three defenders toward him, before slipping a perfect pass behind Rosted and into the path of Thorhallsson. With his first touch of the game, Thorhallsson moved the ball onto his left foot to improve his angle. With his second touch, Thorhallsson slotted a shot past Johnson to make it 4-1 in the 81st minute and remove any doubt about the outcome.

That’s what I took note of on a big night for the Orlando attack. There were still some marking issues defensively on Toronto’s first goal off a corner and the positioning of the defense allowed the second on a ball that was not effectively cleared, but otherwise it was a good performance and one Pareja can build on. What stood out to you? Let us know in the comments below.