Orlando City vs. New York City FC: Final Score 2-1 as Lions Implode, Lose at Home

If Saturday’s 1-1 draw against bottom-feeding Montreal was embarrassing, there might not be an adjective adequate enough to describe tonight’s 2-1 home loss to New York City FC. The Lions (9-6-8, 35 points) led 1-0 late but scored an own goal and then gave up a transition game winner off their own corner kick, failing to win for the fourth straight time at Inter&Co Stadium.

NYCFC (10-8-4, 34) got a late unfortunate own goal from Kyle Smith and Alonso Martinez scored in transition off an Orlando corner kick to erase a 1-0 deficit and steal all three points. It was just the Pigeons’ second road win all season.

“The final just shows us one more time that we’re not a team that can close those games and that just gets us in such frustration at this point,” Orlando City Head Coach Oscar Pareja said after the match. “We highlight the negativity of feeling that the game just slipped from our hands again. I’m responsible for the performance of the group, and today we’re still not finishing the games, and we need to fix that.”

Pareja put Ivan Angulo back in the starting lineup, moving Martin Ojeda back up top with Luis Muriel and sending Ramiro Enrique to the bench. Goalkeeper Pedro Gallese started behind a back line of David Brekalo, Jansson, Rodrigo Schlegel, and Alex Freeman. Cesar Araujo and Eduard Atuesta started in central midfield with wingers Angulo and Marco Pasalic, with Ojeda and Muriel in the forward positions.

Inclement weather delayed the start of the match by about half an hour. Once things got going, Orlando City dominated in creating chances, but as has been the case in recent home matches, the Lions struggled to connect on the final pass or shot.

The teams traded early corners but did nothing with them. Ojeda fired the game’s first shot off of Orlando’s first corner — one of four won by Freeman in the first half — but he sent his effort well wide of goal in the fifth minute.

Angulo was active in his return to the starting lineup, nearly taking the ball from NYCFC goalkeeper Matt Freese in the seventh minute, but the ball skipped out of play off of his deflection.

Muriel got into the box in the 11th minute, trying a shot for the near post, but Freese made the save. Pasalic had a shot blocked high in the box in the 17th minute off an Angulo pass across the area, and three minutes later, Muriel was sent in on a lovely ball but fired his shot right at Freese. Freeman’s shot was blocked out for a corner three minutes later, as Orlando continued to pour forward.

Angulo again set up Pasalic in the 26th minute with a nifty move to get through traffic, but the Croatian’s shot was just wide of the right post. Brekalo had a soft header easily saved by Freese off a corner and Pasalic had another shot partially blocked over the next several minutes, but Orlando couldn’t quite find the last bit of quality.

That changed on another set piece in the 36th minute. Off a corner kick won by Pasalic’s deflected shot, Ojeda sent a ball into the area for Brekalo, who sent it toward goal. Jansson chested it down after being kept onside by Aiden O’Neill, and he turned and beat Freese to make it 1-0. Brekalo and Ojeda assisted on the goal, with the latter picking up a goal contribution for his eighth consecutive MLS game.

After the goal, Orlando won a few set pieces but did little with them. Pasalic had an opportunity to double the lead in the 45th minute, but he got under his left-footed blast and sent it high into The Wall. That was the last decent look of the half and Orlando took its 1-0 lead to the locker room.

At the break, NYCFC had the advantage in possession (51.9%-48.1%), but the Lions had the edge in shots (14-3), shots on target (4-0), corners (8-2), and passing accuracy (86.5%-85.8%).

Ojeda should have doubled the lead early in the second half. With a takeaway in the box, Ojeda had the ball with only Freese to beat around the penalty spot, but he sent his right-footed effort wide of the left post in the 47th minute.

“If you see the volume of the entrances and the clear chances that we had tonight, we have to mention that and say we couldn’t finish,” Pareja said. “I think we need to be more lethal and more precise on finishing those.”

Two minutes later, Ojeda was sent in behind the defense but shot right at Freese and the flag came up.

New York City FC’s Julian Fernandez got the visitors’ first shot on target in the 53rd minute, cutting in from the right and firing. Gallese got down to make the save. Moments later, former Lion Andres Perea got in behind the defense but he was offside and hit his shot at Gallese

Freeman intercepted a pass and started the break in the 58th minute. He ended up getting the ball back after continuing his run. The young fullback faked his defender to the ground, cut inside and sent a shot fizzing over the crossbar.

The visitors should have scored in the 63rd minute. Perea got down the left side and sent in a beautiful curling entry ball for Martinez, who beat Gallese but hit the left post.

Angulo cut inside and fired from just outside the area in the 71st minute, but he sent his shot wide of the right post to spoil another promising attack with a wasteful final ball.

New York City FC began to get more of a hold of the game late, pushing more players forward and getting more opportunities. Mounsef Bakrar got down the right side in the 72nd minute but sent his shot wide of the left post.

Two minutes later, Pareja sent Smith and Dagur Dan Thorhallsson into the game for Pasalic and Angulo, sacrificing some of the team’s creativity in favor of solidity.

Orlando wasted yet another great opportunity in the 79th minute, when second-half sub Ramiro Enrique fired wide of the right post from about nine yards out in front of goal.

New York City came the other way and Bakrar headed a cross straight to Gallese in the 81st minute. Six minutes later, the game turned on a terrible mistake by the Lions.

The visitors won a corner kick on their attacking right side. The cross found Perea’s head, but Gallese got a piece of it, knocking it off the left post. Schlegel swept in to clear the ball, but he smashed it off of Smith and into the net to make it a 1-1 game in the 87th minute. It was the second straight game in which a Schlegel howler proved costly.

Atuesta found space in the 89th minute and fired with his left foot, but he sent his shot well wide of the left post. Orlando won a late corner, but instead of paying it off to regain the lead, the Lions handed New York City FC a breakaway game winner.

The Pigeons cleared and broke quickly with numbers, catching Orlando completely asleep. Thorhallsson was the only player back. He swept at the loose ball and missed, giving Martinez a breakaway. Gallese came out and made himself big, but Martinez beat him and scored the game winner in the first minute of stoppage time.

“I think we obviously were searching for the win on that corner kick. Maybe we just didn’t have the counterattack in mind there, which is obviously wrong not to be cautious on that side,” Angulo said. “We just have to work through it, analyze the game, and correct that.”

Orlando City didn’t exactly fight back. The Lions created nothing in the final three minutes of stoppage time and dropped all three points.

NYCFC finished with more possession (52.1%-47.9%) and better passing accuracy (85%-83.8%). Orlando City had the advantage in shots (25-11), shots on target (7-4), and corners (9-4).

“Difficult to find the words right now,” Angulo said. “It’s a hard game, a loss that hurts us. I think it was a game that we controlled.”

“It doesn’t come from luck, and it has to come from something that we’re not doing right,” Pareja said. “And we have to be responsible for that.”

“Obviously, we conceded their corner, and then on the other side, it was on the set piece as well, just the counter attack,” Freeman said. “So I feel like, you know, those are the things that we need to be more sharp.”

The Lions are 0-3-1 in their last four home matches and have scored just one goal in each of their last five at Inter&Co Stadium. Orlando is 0-5-2 in its last seven matches against NYCFC.

Orlando City will hit the road next for an away game at Gillette Stadium against the New England Revolution on Saturday.