Orlando City Reaches Agreement to Extend Wilder Cartagena through 2026

Orlando City answered one of the questions about the Lions’ 2026 midfield today with the club announcing that veteran Wilder Cartagena has agreed to a new contract through 2026 with a club option for 2027. The club announced the new agreement today.

“Wilder is one of those players who brings so much more than just his performance on the pitch,” Orlando City SC General Manager and Sporting Director Ricardo Moreira said in a club press release. “He’s a true leader in our locker room; someone our players look to both in moments of intensity and in everyday preparation. His experience at the international level and his commitment to excellence make everyone around him better. We’re proud to have him back, he was missed in our 2025 campaign, and know he’ll continue to be a driving force in our pursuit of success and championships.”

The 31-year-old native of Lima, Peru missed the entire 2025 season after sustaining a torn left Achilles tendon in the Lions’ preseason opener against Atletico Mineiro on Jan. 25. He underwent surgery days later and was ruled out for the season.

Orlando City initially acquired Cartagena on loan through the 2022 MLS season. After a successful end of the year, the club exercised the option to extend the loan through the 2023 season. He became a key player in the starting lineup for the Lions that season, resulting in the club signing him to a permanent deal on Dec. 14, 2024. 

The midfielder entered 2025 having enjoyed a solid 2024 season. He appeared in 27 matches during the regular season (25 starts) that year, playing 2,192 minutes. He did not score a goal but recorded an assist and took 24 shots, putting eight on target. He completed 89% of his passes with 16 key passes, one successful cross, and 25 completed long balls. On the defensive side, he recorded 76 tackles, 20 interceptions, 42 clearances, and nine blocks. He committed a team-leading 48 fouls, suffered 28, and received seven yellow cards and one red card, which he picked up after the conclusion of the game against Minnesota United.

During the 2024 MLS playoffs, Cartagena started all five of Orlando City’s matches, playing 431 minutes with no goals or assists. He took two shots, putting one on target, and he completed 87.2% of his passes in the postseason with one key pass. Defensively, he recorded nine tackles, four interceptions, 11 clearances, and one block. He drew eight fouls and committed nine, and he was booked twice, with both being yellow cards.

For his performance across the 2024 campaign, The Mane Land gave Cartagena a season grade of 7.5 out of 10. That was the same grade we gave him in 2023 after not playing enough minutes to earn a grade in 2022.

In his first three seasons in Orlando, Cartagena scored one goal and added three assists in 59 games (52 starts). More importantly, he formed one of the more cohesive central midfield partnerships in the league with Cesar Araujo and provided Orlando City with a defensive shield in the middle to protect the back line. Beyond that, Cartagena also filled in on the back line at times.

In addition to league play, Cartagena has scored a game-winning goal for Orlando City in the 2023 playoff series against Nashville SC, and it was one of the most unforgettable goals in the club’s history.

Cartagena scored another game winner in the 2023 Leagues Cup match against Santos Laguna. He was also one of the key members of the club’s 2022 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup championship team.

Prior to joining Orlando City, Cartagena appeared in 238 competitive matches in his 10-year professional career, scoring seven goals and adding seven assists. The product of Alianza Lima in Peru was promoted to the first team in January of 2012. He transferred to Portuguese club Vitória Setúbal FC in 2014 but did not play during the 2014-2015 season before returning to Lima to play with Universidad San Martín, where he logged 100 appearances and scored three goals from 2015-2017.

Cartagena moved on to Tiburones Rojos de Veracruz in Mexico, playing 24 matches in 2018 before returning to Alianza Lima, where he made 30 appearances in 2019. He then spent 2020-2021 in Argentina with CD Godoy Cruz, where he scored three goals in 20 appearances before moving on to Al-Ittihad Kalba SC in July of 2021. 

On the international stage, Cartagena has amassed 40 caps with the Peruvian National Team, where he was teammates with recently departed Orlando City goalkeeper Pedro Gallese, making his debut on Sept. 5, 2017 in a World Cup qualifier against Ecuador. He has made appearances in the Copa America and the 2018 FIFA World Cup.

What It Means for Orlando City

Re-signing Cartagena is a major piece of Orlando City’s off-season puzzle. Both he and Araujo were out of contract and Eduard Atuesta has only an option year remaining, which as of this writing has not officially been picked up by the club. Gallese has already exited Orlando, center back Rodrigo Schlegel is out of contract, and fellow center back and team captain Robin Jansson, like Atuesta, has an option year remaining. As a result, the team’s defensive end is in flux. Cartagena will be coming off a nasty injury, so there’s no guarantee the 31-year-old will quickly return to form, but if he does, he’s a major addition to the 2026 roster, as he can play the No. 6 role or even play at center back if needed.

The Peruvian adds more bite to an Orlando central midfield that got pushed around more in 2025 than in previous years, as Araujo missed time with injuries, and Atuesta simply isn’t as physical in his own end as either Araujo or Cartagena. That showed in the second half of 2025, when the Lions failed to keep a clean sheet after June 14. Central midfield wasn’t the only reason for a lack of OCSC shutouts, but it was a factor.

With Cartagena in the fold and Araujo reportedly on his way out, it seems logical Orlando will pick up Atuesta’s option year. Rookie Joran Gerbet played well when called upon in his first pro season, but he’ll likely be on the shelf for the start of 2026 after sustaining a knee injury late in the year. Orlando will likely pick up Gerbet’s 2026 contract option, but he won’t be able to help immediately. That will either force Moreira to add another central midfielder or Oscar Pareja may need to elevate Homegrown Colin Guske and hope he’s ready if he’s called upon.

The next eight to 12 weeks will reveal Orlando’s defensive plan for 2026. A new goalkeeper is needed, the center back situation must be sorted out, and the Lions will need to make contract option decisions on Atuesta and Gerbet while possibly looking to add one more body in that position group.