Seb Hines Out as Orlando Pride Head Coach

In the wake of the Orlando Pride’s fourth loss in five games and a 2026 season that is quickly slipping away, the club announced today that it has parted ways with head coach Seb Hines and goalkeeper coach Paul Crichton. In the interim, Assistant Coach Yolanda Thomas will handle head coaching duties.

This move comes with the Pride mired in 12th place in the 16-team NWSL at 8-12-2 and five points below the playoff line. It also takes place less than two years since Hines was named 2024 NWSL Coach of the Year and just two years and 24 days since the Pride gave Hines a new contract through this season with an option for 2027 on Aug. 7, 2024.

“We want to express our gratitude to Seb for the dedication, leadership, and professionalism he brought to the club during his time with us,” Orlando Pride Vice President of Soccer Operations & General Manager Caitlin Carducci said in a club press release. “He will always have a special place in our history for helping lead the Pride to levels it had never reached before. However, as we look toward the club’s long-term vision and future objectives, we believe that this is the appropriate time for a leadership change. We are grateful for all that Seb has contributed and wish him nothing but success in the next chapter of his career.”

Hines, 38, is easily the most successful coach in the club’s history, having signed on as an assistant coach with the Pride in May of 2020 — a few years after the end of his professional playing career. He took over as interim head coach in June of 2022 when then-coach Amanda Cromwell and assistant Sam Greene were placed on administrative leave pending an investigation into potential violations of the league’s policy to prevent and eliminate workplace discrimination, harassment, and bullying. The NWSL concluded that Cromwell and Greene were in violation of that policy and terminated their contracts in October 2022, leaving the future of the team’s coaching position in limbo.

Hines had led the Pride to a seven-game unbeaten run during his stewardship as the investigation went on, but the team also finished that year with a six-game winless skid to quickly drop out of playoff contention. Some felt at the time Cromwell’s contract was terminated that Hines had done enough to win the job, while his 3-7-5 record wasn’t exactly a mandate to hand him the position, nor was the club-record 6-0 loss his team suffered at Portland in his second match in charge.

However, Hines did land the gig. The Pride named him the full-time head coach on Nov. 11, 2022, at the same time the club parted ways with general manager Ian Fleming. Hines led the Pride to the cusp of its first playoff appearance since 2017 during his first full year in charge in 2023. The Pride finished in a three-way tie for fifth on 31 points but fell short of the final playoff spot by losing the goal-difference tiebreaker on the last matchday of the season, when Angel City throttled Portland 5-1 on Decision Day. The Pride beat the Houston Dash by just a 1-0 scoreline that day to get jumped. Orlando had more wins than either fifth-place Angel City or sixth-place Gotham FC (the eventual NWSL Championship winners), but goal difference was the first tiebreaker. It was a heartbreaking end, especially considering an own goal that goalkeeper Anna Moorhouse punched into her own net in the penultimate match against Louisville City turned what could have been a road draw into a road loss.

The Pride set numerous NWSL records under Hines in 2024 and won their first-ever postseason matches on the way to winning the club’s first two trophies — the NWSL Shield and the NWSL Championship. Hines led Orlando to a record of 18-2-6, finishing third in the league in goals scored (46) and tying for first in fewest goals conceded (20). That year’s team set five league records, including most points in a season (60), most wins in a season (18), longest winning streak (8), longest shutout streak (554 minutes), and longest single-season unbeaten run (23 games). The Pride also tied the league record for clean sheets in a season (13). In all, the Pride went 24 NWSL matches without a loss under Hines from the end of 2023 through deep into 2024, when he rotated several players during a road trip to Portland after clinching the NWSL Shield.

Hines led the Pride to a fourth-place finish in the 2025 regular season, earning the team a second consecutive playoff appearance for the first time in club history. The Pride went 11-8-7 in 2025 and reached the NWSL semifinals, losing a late heartbreaker to Gotham FC deep in stoppage time.

The former Orlando City center back leaves the Pride with a career coaching record of 32-38-15 in the regular season (3-7-5 as interim head coach and 29-31-10 as full-time head coach) and 4-1 in the postseason.

“Seb leaves an undeniable legacy with the Pride,” Orlando Pride Owner & Chairman Mark Wilf said in the club’s press release. “His commitment to our players, his staff, and this club helped deliver some of the most important moments in our history. Beyond the results, he helped establish a culture that elevated expectations for what this organization could achieve. We are thankful for everything Seb has contributed and wish him and his family the very best moving forward.”

Thomas joined the Pride as an assistant coach on March 3, 2023. Prior to joining the Orlando staff, Thomas served as sporting director, head coach, and director of coaching with Tulsa Soccer Club and Fortuna Tulsa of the WPSL. She led Tulsa to Franchise of the Year honors in 2019 and 2021 and was named 2019 WPSL Red River Conference Coach of the Year. Over four seasons, Thomas guided Fortuna Tulsa — now known as Tulsa SC — to two conference championships, and appearances in the National Final Four, Regional Championship, and National Elite Eight.  

She previously served as an assistant coach in the college ranks at Oklahoma State University and the University of Tulsa, before becoming head coach at Roger State University.  

She has recently served as the U-23 United States Women’s National Team head coach during two camps in 2025.

Thomas takes over a team that has not scored more than one goal in a match since July 10 and has beaten two of the league’s best teams since NWSL play restarted following the World Cup break but has lost to everyone else. The Pride have been shut out four times in the 10 games since the league restarted.

What It Means for Orlando

While Hines must shoulder his share of the responsibility for the team’s lack of grit and slow development of younger players, it seems clear that his highest highs of 2024 featured a significant number of players elevating their play far beyond anything they’ve shown since. Players such as Summer Yates and Angelina haven’t been anywhere close to their 2024 levels.

Is that coaching or something else? Perhaps the 2024 double-winning season was simply the perfect storm of players buying in; a more talented roster that featured Adriana, Emily Sams, Ally Watt, and a not-yet-gone-on-maternity-leave Kylie Nadaner; the team playing for Luana during her battle with cancer; and the team pushing hard at the end for Marta (who somehow turned back the clock and played as she did in her prime). But the drop-off in quality across the board from returning players on that team and this year is unmistakable, and some players who were fine as bench/role players in 2024 have been asked to log more minutes since, and they haven’t been up to the task.

There is nothing Hines could do about the parade of injury absences the 2026 Pride have endured, and to his credit, he never used it as an excuse. There is also (probably) little Hines could have done about the level of talent he was given on this year’s team. Sams was “replaced” by Hailie Mace and/or Hannah Anderson, depending on how you look at it, but neither player was ever going to provide anything close to what the former NWSL Defender of the Year did during her stay in Orlando. Watt was ostensibly replaced by Nicole Payne, who is also fast but not nearly as polished.

Rafaelle’s fitness issues have been numerous during her Pride career, and this season, her presence has been as big a liability as her absence. Kerry Abello has likewise not been able to get/stay available for selection in 2026. Marta, who has not produced much of her usual magic this year, has had limited availability all season after falling off significantly in form in 2025.

Additionally, Orlando’s commitment to getting younger didn’t work as well as the club had hoped. None of the younger players have panned out (though Solai Washington has shown promising signs), and some of those players have been shipped out on loan to gain experience.

Under Haley Carter, players who were nearing the ends of their deals were locked down early if they were deemed important to the club’s future. Yet this season, we’ve seen only Seven Castain and Cara Martin get extensions thus far, despite the Pride having a number of players either out of contract entirely or coming up on option years at the end of the season.

With all due respect to Castain and Martin, they did not seem like priority signings, considering playing time, but that may be where Hines held different opinions of his players than Carducci. One also wonders whether the reluctance to change goalkeepers amidst Anna Moorhouse’s major struggles in 2026 was a directive from above or solely Hines’ opinion that Moorhouse gave the club the best chance to win and that she would regain her form.

The Pride will now move on, and a new coach isn’t going to be able to find much more success than Hines did — certainly not more than he had in 2024 — without building a team that can adequately defend, win battles in the midfield, and string accurate passes together long enough to work the ball forward to Barbra Banda and Jacquie Ovalle. And better supporting attackers for those two expensive signings must be found as well. Ovalle has not been nearly good enough to justify her pricetag, although the glimpses of what she could provide the club appear from time to time.

There is still time for Orlando to make the playoffs, although the task will be difficult. Thomas is well regarded as a coach and is ready for a head coaching position. This will be her opportunity to see if she can get this Pride roster to elevate its level down the stretch.