Orlando City
2024 Orlando City Season in Review: Rodrigo Schlegel
The Argentine center back showed Papi that he could do that for a fifth consecutive season, refusing to relinquish a starting spot in the second half of the year.
Orlando City originally signed center back Rodrigo Schlegel on loan from Racing Club on Dec. 30, 2019. The Argentine defender signed him to a new permanent deal on Jan. 19, 2022 and then re-signed him again a year later on Jan. 25, 2023 on a deal through that season with option years for 2024 and 2025. City picked up his 2024 option and the 27-year-old native of Remedios de Escalada, Argentina ended up a regular in the starting XI during the team’s strong playoff push in the second half of the season.
Let’s take a look at one of the best seasons yet, and possibly the best season, for the man they call Godrigo.
Statistical Breakdown
Schlegel started a career-high 26 times among his 28 appearances (second-most in his career) this season, logging a total of 2,297 minutes — another career high. He scored one goal — his second career regular-season goal — in 2024 but did not register an assist. The defender attempted 14 shots, putting just four on target. Both of those shots numbers are career highs, with the latter equaling the four shots on goal he fired during the 2021 campaign. You want some more career highs? OK, he set new career marks in pass attempts (1,284) and passing accuracy (90.7%). His four key passes did not set a new career mark, as he eclipsed that mark in 2022, with six. Schlegel did not attempt a cross, but he completed 46 long balls. On the defensive end, Schlegel recorded 41 tackles, 46 clearances, 26 interceptions, 61 aerial duels won, and 10 blocks. He committed 27 fouls, suffered 13, and was shown four yellow cards and one red card.
In the playoffs, Schlegel started all five matches Orlando City played, racking up 449 postseason minutes — just one minute short of the available time the Lions officially played. The defender did not provide a goal contribution but managed to get two of his three shot attempts on target — both numbers are also career highs. He improved his passing rate from the regular season to 91.5%, including a key pass and three successful long balls. Defensively, Schlegel chipped in two tackles, three interceptions, 15 clearances, and two blocks. He committed six postseason fouls, drawing five, and received a pair of yellow cards.
Schlegel appeared in two Concacaf Champions Cup matches (both starts), playing 180 minutes. He didn’t score or assist on a goal, attempting one off-target shot. He completed 90.9% of his 99 passes without a key pass or a cross. Defensively, he chipped in five clearances. The defender committed three fouls, drew one, and wasn’t booked.
In Leagues Cup play, Schlegel made one appearance off the bench, playing just 45 minutes against Atletico San Luis. He did not contribute to a goal, attempting one off-target shot. Schlegel completed nine of his 11 passes (81.8%) on his 22 touches without a key pass or cross. He recorded no defensive stats, committed two fouls in the game, did not draw one, and wasn’t booked.
Best Game
Schlegel was strong defensively in a number of games, including early season narrow losses to the New York Red Bulls and Columbus Crew and the playoff win over Atlanta United. However, I’m going to go with a match in which he helped at both ends of the pitch — Orlando City’s 3-1 road win at FC Dallas. Schlegel started and went the full 90 minutes, scoring a goal on two shots, putting just the one that went in on target, as the Lions got their first-ever win on the road against Dallas. His 93.2% passing rate was on point, although there wasn’t a completed cross or key pass among his 59 attempts. Schlegel contributed three tackles, an interception, and two clearances on the defensive end. He committed two fouls, drew one, and wasn’t booked.
Schlegel’s goal was a great effort on a corner kick taken by Martin Ojeda in the 51st minute, with the Lions up 1-0. Ojeda made a good delivery to an onrushing Schlegel, who came running up from a deeper position than usual. Schlegel made good contact with the cross and guided his header into the upper right corner to make it 2-0, providing some breathing room early in the second half.
Schlegel wasn’t at fault for the Dallas goal, as that came from the penalty spot after a foul by Nico Lodeiro. It was a great night at both ends for the defender.
Although he didn’t win Man of the Match from our own Andrew DeSalvo (that went to Ramiro Enrique), Andrew gave Schlegel an 8 out of 10 and said this about his performance:
Schlegel was everywhere during this match, and a serious contender for Man of the Match. His bullet header that doubled the lead for the Lions will be what is remembered most, but he also had three tackles, two clearances, and one interception, and his partnership with Jansson was excellent in keeping FC Dallas’ pairing of Jesus Ferreira and Petar Musa off the scoresheet. I thought Schlegel was excellent throughout the match, and his right side pairing with Kyle Smith was effective in limiting Dallas’ attacks down their left channel.
In fairness to Andrew, Dave and I didn’t give him MotM either, and maybe all of us should have.
2024 Final Grade
The Mane Land awarded Schlegel a composite score of 7 out of 10 for the 2024 season. This is the same score he received last year, but it looked like a better year on the pitch, and he set a number of career highs, so maybe we just graded too leniently last year or were tougher on him this year than was warranted. Either way, it was a solid year for the veteran defender, and based on his game-by-game match grades, our 7 seems pretty good. He received a 6.5 both in 2022 and in 2021 after earning a 6 out of 10 in 2020 — his first season with the club.
2025 Outlook
Schlegel entered the off-season as the favorite to start alongside captain Robin Jansson in 2025, but he’ll likely get a strong push in preseason by Slovenian international David Brekalo, who did not get to go through a full preseason camp with the Lions in 2024. The Argentine has had a habit throughout his career of playing well for stretches before something derailing it — a random red card or second yellow card, conceding a penalty, or just having a howler of a game where he can’t seem to get himself into the correct position. Many of these are momentary lapses of composure or an act of over-aggressiveness. The 2023However, he mostly played under control throughout the 2024 season, which is a big part of why he managed to hang onto the starting job in the second half of the year.
There is a lot to like about the way Schlegel plays. He isn’t always the best defender on the field, or the most attentive, but he never lacks for effort, plays with an edge to his game that can ruin an opponent’s night, has decent pace to be able to play at this level, and is beloved by his teammates. Obviously, there are center backs who are better in the air or more physically capable of handling the league’s bigger forwards, and his lack of ability to finish on the number of set piece crosses he gets his head onto can be maddening for fans, but he is a solid player. If he’s your third-best center back (in a standard, four-man back line, anyway), you’re thrilled. If he’s your second-best, you might want to upgrade the position.
Time will tell if Brekalo can displace him or if the Lions ever decide to bring in a fourth capable center back rather than relying on Homegrowns in case of emergency. But with Schlegel, you get a solid, if unspectacular, center back option who can either start regularly or spell the starter with quality minutes.