Orlando City
Player Grades: Orlando City vs. Toronto FC
Coming off a reasonably successful start to its first MLS season, Orlando City (2-4-2) has now been soundly beaten in back-to-back matches.
Worse still, the Lions have now failed to score at home in the past three matches in Orlando. In fact, their only home goal all year was the fluky, deflected extra time goal that Kaká scored against NYCFC in the opener.
While it’s tempting to place the blame entirely on the revolving list of starting strikers for City, there’s plenty of blame to go around. Eric Avila failed to test the Toronto keeper on two solid first-half chances, and Kaká has not looked nearly as dominant as he did in the opening weeks.
The absence of Rafael Ramos was clearly a huge blow for the Lions as well. They played extremely narrowly all night, and Kevin Molino was unable to find any space on the right side without the Portuguese youngster’s overlapping runs. His replacement, Tyler Turner, wasn’t horrific, but his crosses were lacking in the opening half and his mistake in the second allowed Toronto’s second goal.
It wasn’t quite the disaster we saw last week against Columbus, but it wasn’t pretty either. Here are our player grades for tonight’s match:
Player Grades
G, Donovan Ricketts, 6 — In another bad defeat, Ricketts again played fairly well. It’s hard to blame him on either goal, though maybe he could have got down a little quicker on the opener. His save in the first minute was excellent, and he denied Sebastian Giovinco 1v1 to keep Orlando in it in the 81st.
D, Brek Shea, 7 — Shea was the Lions’ best player on the night. His crosses were on point, and the entire offense seemed to run through him for much of the first half. Rivas should have scored off Shea’s set up in the 85th to give Orlando a chance at a comeback.
D, Seb Hines, 4.5 — Actually a fairly good night for the Englishman, but his grade suffers because he was beat on both goals. There was plenty of blame to go around on Altidore’s first, but it was Hines who was soundly beaten 1v1.
D, Aurelien Collin, 6.5 — Another solid night for the Lions’ defensive stalwart. Great in the air, and made a number those flailing defensive stops that seemingly only he can pull off.
D, Tyler Turner, 4 — On another day, this may have been a passable fill-in performance for the young right back. However, Orlando’s offensive futility only served to further highlight Turner’s poor crosses and general inability to threaten in attack. He loses a point for his errant trap that led to Toronto’s second goal.
MF, Darwin Ceren, 5 — Ceren seems to be getting more comfortable in attack, but his passes led to one too many turnovers tonight. With Okugo playing a solely defensive role in the middle, the Lions need either Ceren or Higuita to start providing an attacking option in the middle.
MF, Amobi Okugo, 5 — A veteran like Okugo should know that he needs to prevent Altidore from taking the quick free kick that led to the opening goal by any means necessary. He failed to provide anything offensively, and was removed in favor of Carlos Rivas after the opening goal.
MF, Eric Avila, 5.5 — This was Avila’s best match as a Lion, but that’s not necessarily saying much. He was more aggressive offensively in the first half, though his two shots were totally harmless.
MF, Kaká, 6 — With Molino being taken out of the game by Toronto, Kaká was lacking his favorite partner in the attacking third. There were a few too many turnovers, and the Brazilian again failed to get a shot off through 90 minutes.
MF, Kevin Molino, 5 — The Trinidadian was almost completely invisible in this one, though it’s hard to really blame him. With Turner offering hardly any width down the right side, Molino often found himself swarmed by red shirts.
F, Cyle Larin, 5 — Expectations were high for Larin after his first start against Portland, but he’s looked like the rookie that he is in City’s last two matches. He brings a lot of energy up top, but the touch and finishing isn’t really there yet. He had a couple chances in the air that were close, though maybe he could have done better.
Substitutes
D, Carlos Rivas, 5.5 — Entered in the 65th minute in his customary “super-sub” role. He brought energy and pace, but his shot let him down on two good chances in the final 10′. Blasted a particularly good set-up from Shea way over the goal in the 85th.
MF, Bryan Rochez, 4.5 — A rare extended appearance for the Honduran Designated Player, but he did nothing to change Orlando’s offensive fortunes. A bit lucky not to be red-carded for his push/shove/punch on Damien Perquis after provocation from the French-Polish defender.
MF, Danny Mwanga, 4.5 — Bordering on a no-rating, despite playing almost 18 minutes. That tells you just about all you need to know.
* * *
Another rough night in the Citrus Bowl for Orlando City. Thoughts on our player grades? Let us know in the comment section.
The Lions have a bye week friendly against Brazilian side Ponte Preta next Saturday, May 2, at 7 p.m. They return to MLS action the following Friday, May 8, against the New England Revolution in the Citrus Bowl.
Polling Closed
Player | Votes |
Aurelien Collin | 15 |
Brek Shea | 106 |
Kaká | 13 |
Cyle Larin | 1 |
Other | 16 |
Lion Links
Lion Links: 1/28/25
Wilder Cartagena injury reports, Orlando City B’s 2025 schedule, Americans in the UEFA Champions League, and more.
Good morning, everyone! It was nice to get a first look at the 2025 edition of Orlando City on Saturday, but the experience was sullied by an injury that we’ll speak more about shortly. Regardless, we continue to march towards the start of the season with a closed-door scrimmage against Forge FC up next on the docket today. We have a ton to discuss this morning, so let’s get into the links.
Wilder Cartagena Injury Reports
Wilder Cartagena exited Orlando City’s preseason game against Atletico Mineiro with a non-contact injury, naturally leading to fears about what the injury would be. While the club has not released a diagnosis at the time of writing, reports are emerging that the Peruvian midfielder suffered an injury to his Achilles tendon. There are some reports that go as far as saying that he will undergo surgery soon. If true, Cartagena could be sidelined for anywhere from a few months or up to a year, depending on the severity of the injury. We’ll keep you updated as more news becomes available.
Orlando City B Schedule Released
In much more pleasant news, the MLS NEXT Pro schedule was released, which means that we have OCB’s roadmap for the upcoming season. The Young Lions will get the season started at home on Sunday, March 9 against Columbus Crew 2 with a 7 p.m. kickoff. OCB closes the season at home against FC Cincinnati 2 on Decision Day, which will be on Sunday, Oct. 5. The team will play 14 home games, 13 away games, and one at the neutral site of IMG Academy in Bradenton. Most of the games will be streamed on MLS Season Pass on Apple TV, with the rest appearing on mlsnextpro.com.
Americans in Champions League Action
The UEFA Champions League will have its final matchday of the league phase on Wednesday, and there are a lot of Americans who will be competing. Christian Pulisic, Yunus Musah, and AC Milan can guarantee a place in the top eight of the standings with a win when they welcome Dinamo Zagreb to San Siro. Ricardo Pepi, Richy Ledezma, and Esmir Bajraktarević also have a lot to play for with PSV Eindhoven, as a loss or draw risks the club being overtaken and eliminated from the competition. Aside from Juventus, all other teams featuring Americans are placed anywhere from 14th-24th, so the stakes are high during this week’s action.
NWSL News Roundup
Monday was a busy day for the National Women’s Soccer League, so let’s get caught up. The Houston Dash acquired former Orlando Pride forward Messiah Bright in a trade with Angel City FC. The Dash sent $100,000 in inter-league transfer funds to Angel City in exchange, and that number could increase by up to $50,000 with incentives. The Chicago Stars noted that Mallory Swanson has not joined the team for the start of camp due to personal reasons. Jenna Nighswonger has reportedly been sold to Arsenal for a fee of $100,000.
Free Kicks
- Orlando City went old school to bring us a look at Monday morning’s training session.
- The Pride meanwhile, opted for a more traditional route.
- Congratulations are in order for the team of Baby Lions that became the PreMLS NAC Champions for the 2013 age group!
- Former Lion and cowboy hat enthusiast Benji Michel is training with Nashville SC.
- The Columbus Crew have transferred winger Marino Hinestroza to Atletico Nacional.
- Manchester United’s Ruben Amorim dropped an early frontrunner for quote of the year when he said he’d rather start his 63-year-old goalkeeper coach Jorge Vital than Marcus Rashford.
That’s all I’ve got for this morning. Vamos Orlando!
Orlando City
Javier Otero Has the Chance to Prove Himself in 2025
Young goalkeeper Javier Otero can prove himself at the MLS level in 2025.
Orlando City sent backup goalkeeper Mason Stajduhar to Real Salt Lake on Jan. 15 for $50,000 in General Allocation Money and RSL’s natural second-round pick in the 2026 MLS SuperDraft. The move resulted in the end of the Lions’ longest-tenured player, but provides an opportunity for another.
Stajduhar initially signed for the first team on Nov. 9, 2015, as a Homegrown Player. He was largely out of sight for the first few years of his professional career, not even appearing for Orlando City B. However, he eventually became the primary backup to the starter Pedro Gallese and showed his ability. His appearances primarily came early in U.S. Open Cup games or when the primary starter was away on international duty with Peru, but he played well when given the opportunity.
While Stajduhar never made more than six appearances in a season for the MLS side, he had the opportunity to prove himself and his development. It’s hard to say whether the 27-year-old will get more playing time with his new club, but his departure opens the door for another Homegrown goalkeeper.
Born in Venezuela, Javier Otero moved to the United States with his family and joined the Orlando City Academy in 2017 as a 14-year-old. He signed with OCB in 2020, backing up Austin Aviza, and became the regular starter for the Young Lions in 2022 at 17 years of age.
Otero has often been a lifesaver for the Young Lions, being forced to make an incredibly high number of saves. During his first season as a starter, the young shot stopper made a league-high 100 saves from 130 shots on target.
Otero was signed to a Homegrown contract on July 10, 2023, beginning his tenure as a first-team player. He remained with OCB since he was third string, but was forced away from the reserve side when Stajduhar suffered a broken tibia and fibula in his right leg during a June 28, 2024 game in New York. Otero finished the contest, conceding three goals on a difficult night, and backed up Gallese for the remainder of the season.
The injury to Stajduhar left Otero in a bit of a predicament. Since he had to be with the first team as the primary backup, he was unable to play for OCB. As a result, the substitution appearance against New York City FC was his final action in 2024.
Moving Stajduhar and elevating Otero to the primary backup makes sense for the Lions. Gallese doesn’t seem to want to leave and Orlando City isn’t eager for his departure. However, eventually, the 34-year-old Peruvian’s time in Orlando will end and the club needs his replacement. Otero is five years younger than Stajduhar, giving him more time to develop for when Gallese does depart.
The brief appearance by Otero in 2024 clearly isn’t enough to determine if he can play at the MLS level. While he likely won’t play substantial minutes in 2025, he’ll probably have at least five starts throughout the season. This might be during a less important competition than the league or while Gallese is away on international duty.
Gallese is currently on his option year, meaning he’ll be out of contract following the 2025 season unless the club reaches an extension agreement. At this point, it’s hard to see him leaving so soon. But if he does, Orlando City needs to know what it has behind him.
As for Otero, this is his opportunity to prove himself at a higher level. He was fantastic in MLS NEXT Pro action, but MLS competition will provide a much greater challenge than the third division league. This season will give Otero the opportunity to prove to the club and himself that he can take over the number one spot one day, something the higher-ups clearly believe he can do.
The 2025 season will be an interesting one for the Lions. They made the Eastern Conference final last year and are bringing back most of their roster. Despite losing the club’s all-time leading goal scorer, expectations are high that they can match or surpass last year‘s accomplishments.
The upcoming season will also tell us a lot about the future. The departure of Facundo Torres means other players will have to step up. While Gallese will spend the 2025 campaign with the Lions, it’s unclear how long he’ll remain. Otero’s appearances with the first team, no matter their length, will indicate whether he can fill those large shoes when the time comes.
Lion Links
Lion Links: 1/27/25
Orlando CIty wins first preseason match, Naomi Girma completes move to Chelsea, MLS transfer news, and more.
Hello, Mane Landers! I hope all is well with you down in Florida. I’ve been staying busy working and covering high school sports. Besides that, I was able to watch a few Premier League matches over the weekend. Let’s all wish a happy belated birthday to Orlando Pride midfielder Angelina, who turned 25 on Sunday. We have plenty to cover today, so let’s get to the links.
Orlando City Defeats Atletico Mineiro in Penalties After Scoreless Draw
In its first preseason match of 2025, Orlando City edged past Atletico Mineiro 6-5 on penalties after a scoreless draw at Inter&Co Stadium in the FC Series. The Lions had to go through seven rounds of penalties to defeat Atletico Mineiro and clinch the Inter&Co Trophy. Both teams had chances throughout the match, but after 90 minutes of play, the game went to penalties. After being tied 5-5 after six rounds, Joran Gerbet scored in the seventh round andPedro Gallese saved Bruno Fuchs’s shot to win the shootout for the Lions. Orlando City will be in Mexico for camp for the next week and will face Forge FC. The Lions will take on Inter Miami in Tampa on Feb. 14 at Raymond James Stadium.
Lions Reportedly Shift Focus Away From Marco Pasalic
According to Tom Bogert, Orlando City is reportedly shifting their focus from Croatian winger Marco Pasalic to other transfer targets, as the 24-year-old is undecided about his future.
The Lions were reportedly in talks to sign Pasalic from HNK Rijeka last week, as they look to fill their open Designated Player spot following the record-breaking transfer of forward Facundo Torres to Palmeiras last month. The clock is ticking for the Lions to sign a new Designated Player, with Orlando’s season opener set for Feb. 22.
Naomi Girma Completes Record Transfer Move to Chelsea
United States Women’s National Team and former San Diego Wave defender Naomi Girma has completed her transfer to Chelsea in a record-breaking deal. The transfer fee is reportedly agreed at $1.1 million, making her the first player to break the $1 million mark in women’s soccer. Girma signed a four-and-a-half-year deal with Chelsea after three seasons with the Wave. She has 44 caps for the USWNT and was an integral part of the squad that won a gold medal at the 2024 Olympics in Paris.
MLS Transfer Roundup
Major League Soccer had another busy weekend with some notable transfer moves. The Chicago Fire signed midfielder Rominigue Kouame on loan from La Liga 2 side Cadiz CF for the 2025 MLS season, with an option to purchase. The Fire also transferred midfielder Federico Navarro to Argentine first division side Club Atletico Rosario Central for an undisclosed transfer fee. FC Cincinnati is reportedly in negotiations to sign center back Gilberto Flores.
LAFC has agreed to transfer midfielder Mateusz Bogusz to Cruz Azul for a fee reportedly over $10 million. The New York Red Bulls have transferred forward Dante Vanzeir to KAA Gent in Belgium. The Red Bulls have also reportedly expressed interest in signing Tottenham Hotspur forward Timo Werner, who is on loan from Red Bull Leipzig.
Free Kicks
- Former Lion Daryl Dike is close to full fitness and is back training as he looks set to return to action for West Brom. Dike has been recovering from a ruptured Achilles injury from last season that has kept him sidelined for almost a year.
- Christian Pulisic scored a penalty kick, while Yunus Musah added an assist for AC Milan in a 3-2 victory over Parma on Sunday.
- Josh Sargent scored twice in his first start for Norwich City in nearly three months as his side defeated Swansea City 5-1 on Saturday.
- Wolverhampton has reportedly expressed interest in signing Real Betis and USMNT midfielder Johnny Cardoso.
That will do it for me today, Mane Landers. Enjoy your Monday, and I’ll see you next time.
-
Orlando City1 week ago
Striker Suddenly a Position of Need for Orlando City
-
Orlando City2 weeks ago
Orlando City Trades Goalkeeper Mason Stajduhar to Real Salt Lake
-
Orlando City2 weeks ago
A 2025 Orlando City Wish List
-
Orlando City2 weeks ago
Orlando City Signs Colombian Winger Nicolas Rodriguez
-
Lion Links2 weeks ago
Lion Links: 1/15/25
-
Orlando Pride2 weeks ago
Pride Ready to Make a Run for the 2025 Title with a Core from 2024
-
Orlando Pride6 days ago
Orlando Pride Announce 2025 NWSL Schedule
-
Lion Links2 weeks ago
Lion Links: 1/14/25