Connect with us

Orlando City

2025 Orlando City Season in Review: Colin Guske

We kick off our season-ending player grades with a look back at a Homegrown midfielder who got first-team minutes for the first time in 2025.

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City B / Mark Thor

Orlando City signed OCSC Development Academy midfielder Colin Guske to an MLS NEXT Pro contract on April 24, 2024. The club believed in his development and Guske was ready to get regular minutes with OCB. The young central midfielder appeared in 24 matches with OCB last year, starting 23, and provided some stability in the middle of the pitch for the Young Lions, adding a goal and two assists to the attack. He performed well enough to earn a Homegrown Player contract offer, which he signed on Dec. 16, 2024.

Though he was on a first-team contract, the St. Johns native spent his second season with OCB this season, contributing one assist in 18 games (all starts), but he also got his first minutes with the MLS side.

Let’s take a look back at Guske’s 2025 season.

Statistical Breakdown

Guske made his MLS debut on April 5 at Philadelphia in Orlando City’s scoreless draw against the Union, coming off the bench to replace Martin Ojeda for one minute plus stoppage time to help see out a road result against the eventual Supporters’ Shield winners. The 18-year-old appeared in five MLS matches with Orlando City in 2025 — all off the bench — playing a total of just 13 minutes in the regular season as he mainly came in late to prevent a starter from getting a second yellow card, but he earned those minutes. Guske did not post his first MLS goal contribution yet, but he completed all 15 of his passes, including both of his long balls, for a 100% passing rate but did not record a key pass. Defensively, he contributed two clearances, one tackle, and one aerial duel won. Guske committed one foul in the regular season, drew three on the opposition, and received one yellow card.

The teenager also made his MLS playoff debut in 2025, coming off the bench for the final 15 minutes in Orlando City’s 3-1 wild card loss to the Chicago Fire. Those 15 minutes surpassed his 13 regular-season minutes. He passed at an 89% rate and committed three fouls without drawing one, but he was not booked. On the defensive end, Guske contributed a clearance and won an aerial duel.

Guske came off the bench against the Tampa Bay Rowdies and played 45 minutes in the U.S. Open Cup on the road on May 7 in Orlando City’s 5-0 win. He did not have a goal contribution but created one good scoring chance for Ramiro Enrique, although the Argentine missed the target. He completed 19 of his 20 passes (95%), including both of his long balls. On the defensive end, Guske added two interceptions and a recovery, blocking one shot.

Best Game

This is an easy choice, as Guske played well and contributed in his longest outing of the season with the first team. His 45-minute performance against the Tampa Bay Rowdies helped the Lions defeat their I-4 rivals and complete the shutout. His passing rate of 95% was among the best on the team and Enrique should have done better with the pass with which Guske cut the Rowdies wide open in the 86th minute.

2025 Final Grade

Guske fell well short of the required 450 combined minutes (regular season, playoffs, U.S. Open Cup, and Leagues Cup) to qualify for a grade for the season with the first team. The Mane Land will therefore have to give him an incomplete rating.

2026 Outlook

The young midfielder has a bright outlook with Orlando City in 2026. Guske is under contract through 2027 with a club option for 2028. It is uncertain whether fellow central midfielders Cesar Araujo, Eduard Atuesta, or Wilder Cartagena will be back, although almost certainly at least one of those three will be back in purple.

Araujo’s 2022 deal was through 2024 with an option year in 2025, which was automatically triggered by his performance last season. The Uruguayan has been the subject of reports of him returning to South America, and it’s unusual for the Lions not to re-sign a player of Araujo’s caliber before he’s out of contract. The press release for Cartagena’s deal through 2025 did not mention option years and the 31-year-old Peruvian will be returning from an Achilles injury. Atuesta’s contract is only through this season with an option year for 2026. It’s possible that all three could be back, none of them, or any one or two of them.

Guske is in a position where he could start seeing more minutes with the first team, with OCB still there for him to get playing time if he isn’t ready. In a perfect world, Guske would make a leap like Alex Freeman did from 2024 to 2025. It is more likely he’ll need a little more developmental time, despite impressing enough to work his way into the U.S. youth international picture. Central midfield is a physical position at the MLS level. I look for Guske to get a long look in training camp and be in the rotation in 2026. If he can’t win a starting position, I look for him to be a fixture on the Orlando bench and play matches with OCB.


This is the first of our 2025 Orlando City Season in Review articles. Every player who played minutes this past season and who finished the year on the club roster will be reviewed (exceptions may be made for players let go when the club officially announces its roster moves). For example, Yutaro Tsukada and Wilder Cartagena will not receive grades because they did not play any minutes and Ramiro Enrique will not be rated due to transferring out before the end of the season. Likewise, Justin Ellis played two minutes with the first team but is on an MLS NEXT Pro contract, not an MLS deal, so he will not be graded.

Players who logged more than 450 minutes (combined regular season plus playoffs, U.S. Open Cup, and and Leagues Cup) will receive a composite score between 1 and 10 as determined by a panel of The Mane Land writers, while those who did not reach that threshold will receive an incomplete grade.

Orlando City

More Spice or Less? Tyrese Spicer as Starter vs. Substitute

Tyrese Spicer’s performances as an OCSC starter and substitute, and how he ranks as against offensive subs in MLS.

Published

on

Image of Tyrese Spicer attempting a cross against Colorado in a preseason friendly.
Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

Back in 2015, I worked for a company that assigned me to a project for a company in Trinidad & Tobago, and I spent about half a year traveling back and forth from Orlando to Port of Spain, the capital city. I loved everything about my time in Trinidad & Tobago, and while I promise this will move to soccer shortly and not become a travelogue or a food blog, I have to briefly mention my discovery there of a food called “doubles.”

Doubles are often eaten as a breakfast food but are delicious at any time of the day. Much like with cheesesteaks in Philadelphia, there is a language associated with ordering them. A doubles order usually consists of how many you want and how hot you would like them to be. I do not have a high tolerance for heat, so I often ordered mine with “no pepper,” (tell me you are an American without telling me you are an American), but Trinis generally go with at least slight pepper and often medium or heavy pepper.

All of that discussion of Trinidad & Tobago and pepper brings us to a man who comes from the twin islands and literally has spice in his last name — Tyrese Spicer.

Spicy T was the Man of the Match in our player grades from Orlando City’s most recent MLS game after contributing a goal and an assist. He scored his fourth goal of the MLS season, which ranks second on the team behind Martín Ojeda’s 11. Spicer scored that goal after coming off the bench to replace Tiago, and his bench goal was the seventh for the Lions this season, which ties them for the league lead in goals scored by substitutes:

TeamSubstitute GoalsTotal Goals*Substitute Goal %
Orlando City73023%
Cincinnati74416%
Seattle62030%
Miami64414%
Portland53216%
Dallas53116%
St. Louis52322%
Nashville53514%

*Excludes opposition own goals

All four of Spicer’s goals in MLS play have come as a substitute, and he is tied for the league lead with Cincinnati’s Tom Barlow in that category:

PlayerTeamSubstitute Goals
Tyrese SpicerOrlando City4
Tom BarlowCincinnati4
Christian RamirezAustin3
Samuel SarverDallas3
Peyton MillerNew England3

During the entire 2025 MLS season the league leaders in substitute goals scored only four goals off the bench, and Spicer has already reached that tally through Orlando City’s first 18 league games.

Extrapolating those 18 games to the full season would put Spicer on pace for 7.56 goals, and since he has scored all of his goals off the bench, the extrapolation for goals as a substitute would also be for that same amount, which would be the most in MLS since Dejan Joveljić scored eight goals as a substitute for the LA Galaxy in 2022.

A logical question would be: If Spicer is scoring all these goals in limited minutes as a substitute, should Orlando City just make him a starter?

On the surface, it seems like an obvious no.

Put aside the fact that leading scorer Martín Ojeda is out injured but will command a starting spot when he returns, likely at the same left wing position where Spicer usually plays, another fact is that since joining Orlando City in August of 2025, Spicer has played demonstrably better off the bench than as a starter across all competitions (data from Opta’s tracking on fbref.com):

RoleMinutes PlayedGoalsPrimary AssistsGoal Contributions per 90 mins
Starter457200.39
Subtitute557541.45

In recent years, Orlando City has benefitted from “supersubs,” as Spicer’s four goals thus far in 2026 marks the fourth consecutive season in which a Lion has scored at least four goals in a season as a substitute. Duncan McGuire started the trend with five in 2023 and added four in 2024. Ramiro Enrique followed with four off the bench in 2025 (and likely would have scored more that had he not transferred in August; I really wish he had stayed. Sigh.), and now Spicer has four in 2026 with many games still to play. McGuire’s five in 2023 is the joint club record with Júlio Baptista, as The Beast lived up to that moniker when coming off the bench in 2016, but Spicer is hot on their heels.

Some players simply perform better off the bench, and Spicer, at least so far, seems to be in that Manu Ginóbili mold of a player with starter-level talent that is better at finishing games than starting them.

Orlando City General Manager and Sporting Director Ricardo Moreira noted this when the club acquired Spicer from Toronto, saying that the Trinidad & Tobago international player would “bring additional depth and energy” and that “his relentless work rate and ability to stretch the field will give us a much-needed boost and add another dimension to our attack moving forward.”

Spicer’s boosts off the bench have led to two game-winning goals this season, the fourth in the amazing 4-3 comeback victory over Inter Miami in May and the only goal in the 1-0 home victory over Nashville at the end of July.

August is a packed month for Orlando City, with at least eight games on the calendar and possibly nine, depending on how the Lions do in Leagues Cup. We’ll see throughout the rest of August (this article was written before the Leagues Cup game against CF Monterrey, which had Spicer in the starting lineup) if Martín Perelman is locked in to using Spicer as a supersub or gives him additional chances as a starter, as there will need to be some rotation with games every three to four days.

The numbers say that Perelman should keep looking for someone to hold down the left wing for the first portion of the game and bring in Spicer to close, but Orlando City’s poor play on the left side of the field in the first half helped dig a hole it could not climb out of against the Red Bulls, and this is a critical part of the season, so getting positive results is of paramount importance.

I’m looking forward to finding out if Perelman makes the call to go from no pepper to Spicy T as a frequent left wing starter, at least until Ojeda returns. The numbers are against it, as am I, but we shall see what Perelman orders.

Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Orlando City

Pasalic Remains in Purple

Marco Pasalic is staying. What does that mean for Orlando City’s season?

Published

on

Image of Marco Pasalic trying to create space to shoot against Columbus.
Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

At least for the moment, it seems the Marco Pasalic to Hull City transfer is a bust. With the Croatian back in the mix for Orlando City, the team will have two of three Designated Players available. Unfortunately, we’re still waiting for Martin Ojeda to make it back from his injury. In the meantime, the return of the left-footed, Croatian rocket launcher is a good thing, right? Let’s take a look at the arguments for and against, and how it affects the rest of the squad.

More Firepower

Pasalic has the potential to contribute a significant number of goals for Orlando City. We haven’t seen what he can do when on the pitch with Antoine Griezmann, who can create space for Pasalic on the right side of the box. Griezmann can drag defenders to the left, allowing Pasalic more of an opening to unleash his signature top-of-the-box shot. Griezmann or Justin Ellis will be able to provide slick, no-look passes to a hopefully wide-open Pasalic.

Additionally, if Pasalic regains his form, the threat he poses will allow the left side of the attack some more space to move. There’s also the Daryl Dike factor. Once the big man is fully integrated back into the attack, there is a veritable smorgasbord of attacking options for an attack-oriented Martin Perelman to employ. He does seem to have an “all gas, no brakes, who needs defense” approach to tactics. Obviously, that is hyperbole, but not by much.

All of this is contingent on Pasalic resetting his mindset to give 100% to Orlando City. As a professional, I expect he will believe he is going to do so, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy, given he obviously wanted to make a move back to Europe. Recommitting to a team you thought you were leaving is never easy, no matter what anyone says.

Defensive Implications

If Orlando City had sold Pasalic, there would have been an infusion of cash available to help build the roster. I think it unlikely that a new Designated Player could be signed before the secondary window closes. That kind of money could be used on a decent left back, another veteran center back, or help in the defensive midfield. Maybe even all of the above.

Now, the money is tied up and the defense still has so many challenges. I don’t think Pasalic’s offensive production will be able to overcome the goals the defense will give up the rest of the season. Not losing a Designated Player at this point of the season is generally a good thing, especially with Ojeda being injured, though I’m not convinced things are actually better with Pasalic staying. Of course, even if he had been sold, there’s no guarantee that Ricardo Moreira would reinforce the defense in the transfer window.


I’m hopeful that Pasalic rededicates himself to Orlando City and starts to produce some goals for the Lions, because given this defense, the team will need as many goals as possible. Let us know your thoughts on how Pasalic staying plays out. Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Lion Links

Lion Links: 8/6/26

Orlando City beats Monterrey, Marco Pasalic reportedly staying in Orlando, Zambia ousted from Women’s Africa Cup of Nations, and more.

Published

on

Image of Marco Pasalic saluting the fans.
Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

It’s Thursday, which means we’re celebrating an Orlando City victory. The Lions have been midweek monsters this season and it’s been a nice boost of energy to get through the week. If any of you are performing some sort of ritual on Wednesday nights, please keep it up. Let’s get to the big win and more in today’s links!

Orlando City Beats Monterrey in Leagues Cup

After a lengthy weather delay, Orlando City beat Monterrey 2-1 at home in its first match of this year’s Leagues Cup. The video review system was put through its paces in this match, overturning a Monterrey goal, a Monterrey red card, and a penalty on Orlando’s Robin Jansson in separate instances. Be sure to check out our recap of the win, which included a nice performance from Tyrese Spicer as a starter and the return of Daryl Dike off the bench. The Lions will be back in action on Saturday against Club Leon before wrapping up this phase of the tournament on Wednesday against San Luis.

Marco Pasalic Reportedly Staying in Orlando

There’s been buzz this summer regarding Marco Pasalic being transferred form Orlando City to Hull City, but the move is reportedly not going to happen according to Croatian sports newspaper Sportske Novosti.

Pasalic had 12 goals and five assists in his first MLS season last year after joining Orlando from HNK Rijeka. While the 25-year-old hasn’t quite had the same impact so far this season, he did play for Croatia in this summer’s World Cup and could benefit from the addition of Antoine Griezmann to the offense. Pasalic came off the bench for a late cameo on Wednesday to help see out the win over Monterrey.

Zambia Eliminated From WAFCON Despite Win

Orlando Pride forward Barbra Banda scored in Zambia’s 2-1 win against Malawi in the Women’s Africa Cup of Nations, but it wasn’t enough for Zambia to avoid elimination. Zambia, Malawi, and Nigeria all finished with six points in the group stage, but Zambia was ousted due to the third tiebreaker of goals scored in matches between the three. It’s a rough way to go out for Zambia, which finished with the best overall goal differential in the group. As a result, Zambia will not take part in the 2027 Women’s World Cup. Banda finished the tournament with five goals and will return to a Pride team in desperate need of help on offense.

U.S. Qualifies for 2027 U-20 Men’s World Cup

The United States U-19 Men’s National Team beat Guatemala 3-1 to advance to the semifinals of the Concacaf U-20 Men’s Championship, qualifying for the 2027 U-20 World Cup and 2027 Pan American Games in the process. Guatemala struck first, but the U.S. found an equalizer right before halftime and went on to win the game with a pair of goals in the second half. Orlando City midfielder Colin Guske was a starter in the match as well. The U.S. will take on Costa Rica in the semifinals Friday at the Azteca.

FIFA Backs Gianni Infantino as Pressure Rises

As the soccer world reacts to FIFA President Gianni Infantino’s failed scheme to sell stakes in the World Cup, FIFA reaffirmed its support for him at a crisis meeting in Morocco over his presidency. There have been many calls for reform due to Infantino’s actions, with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney stating he does not have confidence in him and Portuguese legend Luis Figo calling for him to step down. FIFA also denied a report that Infantino offered Morocco hosting for the 2030 World Cup final in exchange for support.

Free Kicks

  • Former Lion Nico Lodeiro announced his retirement from professional soccer and Orlando City General Manager and Sporting Director Ricardo Moreira wished him the best with one of his highlights as a Lion.

That’s all I have for you this time around. I hope you all have a wonderful Thursday and rest of your week!

Continue Reading

Trending