Orlando City
Orlando City vs. New York Red Bulls: Player Grades and Man of the Match
Undefeated feels so good. Orlando City maintain its perfect record at home with a grind-it-out 1-0 victory over the New York Red Bulls. Servando Carrasco, of all people, provided the only goal of the match — the first non Cyle Larin goal for Orlando this year.
Let's get to the grades:
Starters
GK, Joe Bendik, 7.5 – Overall, a solid performance once again from Bendik. Came up with a great save on a Bradley Wright-Phillips shot in the 8th minute. Had multiple big stops, mostly on Wright-Phillips, but still was not great on distribution to create attacks.
D, Scott Sutter, 7.5 – A solid shift for his first ever MLS start. Read the game well and was able to bomb forward in the attack as well as track back on defense. Had an effort on goal that barely sailed over in the 22nd minute and had another good effort in the 42nd that just rolled past the post.
D, Jonathan Spector, 8 (MotM) – The most consistent player so far this season for Orlando City came up with a huge defensive performance. Not only on an individual level, but the commanding of the back line and the teamwork with youngster Tommy Redding provided the framework for the team's second shutout in four games. Had the great goal-line clearance in the 12th minute to save a goal after Bendik got the initial save.
D, Tommy Redding, 7.5 – A decent game for the 20-year-old defender. Struggled a bit to win balls in the air against stronger and taller players, but was able to make up for it on the ground. Played well in tandem with Spector and together they were able to communicate well on the back line to knock out most of the Red Bulls’ chances. Led the team in interceptions and clearances. Mistimed a challenge on BWP in the 51st, almost letting in a chance.
D, Donny Toia, 7 – Solid job on the left fullback side. Didn’t have too much to deal with defensively, but broke up some promising attacks when they came his way. Third on the team in interceptions and tackles and fourth in clearances.
MF, Will Johnson, 7.5 – Struggled to make an impact through the first half the game, but along with Carrasco he managed the midfield well and helped create chances going forward. Had more impact as the match went on and finished the game second in tackles. Had the perfect set piece on the corner to Carrasco for the only goal.
MF, Antonio Nocerino, 6 – Looked solid in the beginning of the match, but a calf strain forced him to be subbed out in the 17th minute. He’ll be evaluated on Monday.
MF, Cristian Higuita, 7 – An impressive performance from the Colombian. Was strong on the ball and used tight, close dribbling to get around defenders, which created attacking chances. Was his usual self on the defensive end and even got his usual yellow card in the 61st minute. Was fouled the most (5 times) out of any Orlando player. Slipped Rivas in on goal in the 58th but his Colombian counterpart muffed the opportunity.
MF, Matias Perez Garcia, 7.5 – Looked much more dangerous as the center attacking midfielder than on the wing. Led the team in key passes and tackles. Head Coach Jason Kreis pointed out his defensive work rate through the match. Excellent opportunity in the 24th minute, with his shot curling just past the post. Had the perfect pass up field to Larin in the 67th minute, which led to a one-on-one chance with Robles.
F, Carlos Rivas, 6.5 – His pace caused problems for the Red Bulls, but overall, he was just okay. Solid effort in the 14th minute after good combination passing and forced a tough save from Robles. Had a good nutmeg pass to MPG in the 24th to get an effort on goal. Made a good run in the 38th minute, forcing his way past defenders to get into Red Bulls territory. Good back-post cross to find Larin in the 51st minute, but the chance wasn’t converted. Missed a good chance in the 58th minute after Higuita slipped him into the box and he lost the ball. Had two free kicks, but both went over goal — albeit not into lunar orbit, as can sometimes happen with him.
F, Cyle Larin, 7 – The big striker put himself in good space and made some good, strong runs towards goal, but the finishing touch was off today. Missed a good chance in the 51st minute on a back post cross from Rivas. Went 1-v-1 with Robles off MPG’s long pass in the 67th minute but couldn’t beat the New York keeper.
Substitutes
MF, Servando Carrasco (17’), 7.5 – Came in for Nocerino and provided good midfield depth. Scored the only goal in the 34th minute off a corner kick from Johnson, proving to be the eventual game winner. His forward passing and long balls were a bit off today, but his defensive coverage on the ground was solid.
MF, Giles Barnes (68’), 6 – Played some solid defense after coming on for MPG and helped Orlando preserve the lead. Earned a free kick in a good spot in the 80th minute and was strong on the ball in the limited opportunities he had.
MF, Luis Gil (83’), 6 – Made his first appearance for Orlando City and was shown a yellow card after only two minutes after coming on. Other than that, he didn’t get a chance to do too much. Did have a good defensive play in the 87th minute.
That’s how I saw tonight’s performances. Let us know what you thought below and be sure to vote for your Orlando City Man of the Match.
Polling Closed
Player | Votes |
Jonathan Spector | 157 |
Servando Carrasco | 59 |
Matias Perez Garcia | 7 |
Cristian Higuita | 23 |
Joe Bendik | 25 |
Other (Tell us in the comments) | 3 |
Opinion
Likes and Dislikes from this Week of Orlando City’s Preseason
Orlando City’s third week of preparation had some good things and some not so good things.
We have another week of Orlando City’s preseason in the books, and while it seems hard to believe, it’s been almost three weeks since the Lions got back in the lab and started preparing for the 2025 campaign. There have been lots of new talking points this week too, and its been a bit of a mixed bag. Let’s have a look at some of the good and bad from this past week.
Likes
Victory (Kind of) vs. Atletico Mineiro
Okay, so it technically wasn’t a victory since the game ended in a scoreless draw. The Lions did get the job done from the penalty spot though, as they won the shootout 6-5 to claim whatever the Inter&Co Trophy is. More important than the result though, was the fact that OCSC played pretty well. Orlando created a good amount of opportunities, but as seems to be the fatal flaw with this team, the finishing was definitely on the rusty side. It was perhaps unlucky that some of the Lions’ best chances fell to youngsters, but the good news is that the chances were being created. It was a positive first showing that the team can hopefully build on.
Back in the U.S. Open Cup
A lot of fans, myself included, had big issues with the Lions not being a participant in the U.S. Open Cup last year. It’s a tournament that is near and dear to a lot of Orlando fans, given that OCSC has won the whole damn thing once, had other special moments like The Running of the Wall, and has generally made decent runs in the competition. It was welcome news to hear that Orlando will be back in the competition this year, along with 15 other MLS teams that will enter the competition during the Round of 32. The tournament has a charm and a special place in my heart, and it’s exactly where the Lions should be.
Two Games, Two Clean Sheets
Nic Josey has gone on the record stating that Orlando City will need strong, steady performances from its defense if the team wants to avoid a slow start to the season like we saw in 2024. It’s only preseason, and we shouldn’t get too carried away, but so far so good, as the Lions have recorded a clean sheet in each of their two preseason games. Whether that will mean a damn thing once the regular season starts is anyone’s guess, but it’s a hell of a lot better than giving up buckets of goals in the preseason.
Dislikes
Wilder Cartagena’s Injury
We still don’t have official confirmation on the injury that Wilder Cartagena suffered during Saturday’s preseason match, but all the reports point to an Achilles Tendon injury, with ESPN’s Diego Montalvan going as far to say that he’ll be undergoing surgery. If that proves to be the case then it’s a doomsday scenario indeed for the Lions, as Cartagena could miss anywhere from six months to a whole year. He’s proven to be a vital part of what makes Orlando City tick, and replacing him is going to be far from an easy task.
Summer Fixture Frenzy
Along with the U.S. Open Cup, the Lions will once again be participating in Leagues Cup, and that’s presented them with a hellish slate of matches to finish out the summer. In a stretch from mid-July to mid-August OCSC will play a positively hellish eight games in 29 days, with that number potentially rising even higher if the club goes deep in the Open Cup (unless the two competitions decide to play nice and work with each other on scheduling). Not to mention that six of those eight games will take place at home in the punishing Florida heat and humidity. Either some guys are going to need to get signed, the kids are going to get some good experience, or something is going to give. Speaking of…
The Continued Wait for Reinforcements
Orlando City has made a couple signings in the last two weeks, with the most notable of those being winger Nicolas Rodriguez, with goalkeeper Carlos Mercado getting re-signed on Thursday. That’s a start, but Cartagena needs to be replaced, Jack Lynn’s retirement and Duncan McGuire’s shoulder injury mean the striker corps is dangerously thin, and the team could use help with depth at midfield and fullback. That’s a hell of a lot of business that needs to get done, and there hasn’t been much in the way of substantive chatter in the transfer rumor mill lately. The sooner signings are made, the more time they have to get integrated with their new surroundings before the season starts, but time is fast running out for that to happen.
There you have it folks. Life is full of peaks and valleys, and this week for Orlando City was a good reflection of that. What things jumped out to you this week, and what are you hoping to see as we move into the fourth week of preseason? Be sure to have your say down in the comments. Vamos Orlando!
Lion Links
Lion Links: 1/31/25
Orlando Pride transfer Adriana for record fee, Orlando City re-signs Carlos Mercado, new Leagues Cup format revealed, and more.
Happy Friday, Mane Landers! Today ends the first month of 2025 and my resolutions are mostly intact. I’d like to walk a bit more in the afternoons than I currently am, but I’ll take what I can get. I don’t have too many plans lined up this weekend beyond working, catching some sports, and board games with friends. But for now, let’s dive into today’s links from around the soccer world.
Adriana Transferred For Orlando Pride Record Fee
The Orlando Pride have transferred Adriana to Al Qadsiah FC in the Saudi Women’s Premier League for a club record fee of reportedly $500,000. Adriana requested the move after two seasons with the Pride since joining in January of 2023. The versatile attacker recorded 12 goals and five assists in 46 regular-season appearances with the Pride. This move opens up an opportunity for more minutes for the team’s young players, and that transfer fee should help improve the Pride’s roster.
Carlos Mercado Re-Signs With Orlando City
Orlando City signed goalkeeper Carlos Mercado to a new contract through the upcoming 2025 season, with club options for 2026 and 2027. The club declined the option on his previous contract following the 2024 season, but he’s back in purple after Mason Stajduhar’s trade to Real Salt Lake. The 25-year-old will likely feature as Orlando City B’s starting goalkeeper this season, with Javier Otero backing up Pedro Gallese on the first team. Mercado started 20 games for the Young Lions last season, so he has some playing time and familiarity with the team under his belt ahead of the 2025 MLS NEXT Pro season.
Leagues Cup Reveals New Format for 2025
Orlando City was one of only 18 MLS clubs to qualify for this summer’s Leagues Cup and we now know what the new format for the tournament will be. The group stage is gone and in its place is a convoluted first phase that can be simplified as there being six sets of six teams —three from MLS and three from Liga MX. Each team will play one match against the three teams from the opposing league, and then only the top four teams overall from each league will advance to the quarterfinals. This means that there will be MLS vs. Liga MX matchups every game until possibly the semifinals. One rule that stuck around though is that there will still be a penalty shootout for an additional point if two teams draw.
NWSL Awards Franchise to Denver
The NWSL officially announced that the league’s 16th franchise will be in Denver. The new club will take the field in 2026 and is finalizing plans to build a stadium for the team. Rob Cohen, who founded the Denver Sports Commission to help bring major sporting events to the city, will serve as the club’s controlling owner and governor, while Mellody Hobson will be the alternate governor. Denver’s team doesn’t have a name, colors, or a logo just yet, but I think anything other than DEN Nation FC would be a good idea.
Free Kicks
- Former Pride player Emily van Egmond joined Birmingham City on a two-and-a-half-year contract after three years with the San Diego Wave. Birmingham is at the top of the Women’s Championship in a tight race for promotion to the Women’s Super League.
- Manuel Cocca, whose contract with Orlando City B expired after last season, has joined Arsenal de Sarandi in Argentina’s second division.
- Miguel Almiron officially returned to Atlanta United from Newcastle United for a reported $10 million transfer fee, signing a contract through 2027 with an option for 2028. Atlanta also sent $400,000 in General Allocation Money to Charlotte FC for his discovery rights, which is peak MLS.
- Minnesota United signed center back Nicolas Romero as an MLS U22 Initiative Player.
- American forward Ricardo Pepi’s knee injury suffered in PSV Eindhoven’s win against Liverpool may keep him sidelined for two months. Hopefully that’s not the case, as he would miss out on the Concacaf Nations League games in March.
- Temwa Chawinga signed a three-year contract extension with the Kansas City Current. She scored 20 goals last season and was named NWSL MVP in her first year in the league.
- Manchester United, Tottenham, and Olympiacos all secured a spot in the Europa League’s round of 16 after winning on the final matchday of the league phase. The draw for the knockout phase is today, and there should be some interesting matchups with teams like Roma, Porto, and Galatasaray eager to make the round of 16.
- Chelsea has reportedly agreed to sign English midfielder Keira Walsh from Barcelona.
That’s all I have for you this time around. I hope you all have a fantastic Friday and rest of your weekend!
Opinion
Orlando City’s Lack of Off-Season Signings Starting to Become a Concern
The Lions’ roster hasn’t gotten any bigger in the last few weeks, so it’s understandable if fans are getting a bit antsy.
Three weeks ago I wrote that there was no reason to panic about Orlando City’s lack of off-season signings. It was early in January, and the club typically does a lot of its business throughout the first month of the year. Since then, the club signed Nicolas Rodriguez, but the Lions also traded Mason Stajduhar, and forward Jack Lynn retired. That is more subtraction than addition for a team looking to make it to the next level. Is it now time to panic?
The departure of Stajduhar hits Orlando City supporters in the feels given how long he was with the club, but one may assume the coaches have seen enough from Javier Otero to be confident in his ability to back up Pedro Gallese. The club still needs to bring in another keeper [Editor’s note: this story was written prior to the club signing Carlos Mercado this morning], but Stajduhar’s departure isn’t as big of a problem as it might first seem.
We don’t know how long Duncan McGuire will be unavailable once the season starts. Even if he’s back sooner than expected, Orlando City will still be lacking at the striker position. Ramiro Enrique has proven he can be a starter, but with Jack Lynn’s departure, there isn’t anyone behind him. While Luis Muriel is technically a striker, he tends to play further back in a facilitator role rather than as an actual No. 9. We haven’t seen any transfer moves for a new striker.
The Lions got a big influx of cash, thanks to the Facundo Torres deal. Replacing the goal production of Orlando City’s all-time leading goal scorer is a priority. So far, the club has brought in Rodriguez as an MLS U22 Initiative player. Despite the similarities between the two, Rodriguez is not a replacement for Torres. It is unrealistic to expect the young man to score double-digit goals his first year in MLS.
I’m not even worried about the attacking midfield. As I mentioned above, Muriel is best as a facilitator, Martin Ojeda is now wearing the No. 10 jersey, and Ivan Angulo can play on either side. It’s Torres’ goal contributions I’m worried about missing. Orlando City needs to replace that production sooner rather than later or another slow start seems certain.
I’m not going to address the Wilder Cartagena injury until we know more, but that is also potentially very bad news. That brings us to today. The team is already deep into its preseason trip to Mexico. This is the trip that in the past has been the time when the team truly bonds. Any players brought in at this point will obviously miss that valuable time.
Additionally, unless a signing is someone who has already played in MLS — which is incredibly rare for this front office — it is going to take them time to adapt to the league as well as the club and their new teammates. That brings us back to the real potential for another slow start to the season.
When you have roster turnover, the idea is to bring in players that are better than the players that departed. We know that the ownership is serious about winning. The 2022 Open Cup victory and the Orlando Pride’s two 2024 trophies are a testament to that. Now, it’s time to see that commitment with some substantial signings for City. In some ways, I feel the club has left it a little late, but I’ll take what I can get at this point.
I’m not saying it’s time to panic — though I won’t tell you not to do so — but I’m definitely getting a bit concerned. Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.
-
Orlando City2 weeks ago
Striker Suddenly a Position of Need for Orlando City
-
Orlando Pride1 week ago
Orlando Pride Announce 2025 NWSL Schedule
-
Orlando Pride2 weeks ago
Pride Ready to Make a Run for the 2025 Title with a Core from 2024
-
Orlando City2 weeks ago
Orlando City Signs Colombian Winger Nicolas Rodriguez
-
Orlando Pride2 weeks ago
Orlando Pride Announce 2025 Preseason Camp Roster
-
Opinion2 weeks ago
Likes and Dislikes from the First Week of Orlando City’s Preseason
-
Orlando City6 days ago
Orlando City vs. Atletico Mineiro, FC Series: Final Score 0-0 (6-5) as Lions Open the Preseason Schedule Strong
-
Orlando Pride1 week ago
A 2025 Orlando Pride Wish List