Connect with us

Orlando City

Orlando City vs. New York Red Bulls: Final Score 1-0 as Lions Come Up Short in Good Fight with Shield Winners

Orlando City ends 2018 with a narrow road loss at Red Bull Arena.

Published

on

Carlos Romero, The Mane Land

A valiant effort from Orlando City came up short as the New York Red Bulls claimed the Supporters Shield on Decision Day, thanks to a 1-0 victory. Orlando (8-22-4) had several opportunities to come away with a result but New York (22-7-5) proved too strong on the day. With Atlanta United’s loss to Toronto FC, the Red Bulls topped the final table and set a new record for points in a season. Orlando ends its 2018 campaign with a loss and finishes on just 28 points, the club’s lowest in its short MLS history.

The Lions also lost their final 14 consecutive road matches.

Head Coach James O’Connor named a largely unchanged side from the Lions’ 2-1 victory over Columbus, with Carlos Ascues (quad injury) making way for Amro Tarek and Chris Mueller in instead of Will Johnson in the front three. Lamine Sané sustained a knee injury in pregame warm-ups and was replaced by Chris Schuler in the center of the three-man back line. Sacha Kljestan was given the captain’s armband in his return to Red Bull Arena. Don’t mind the shape on the graphic.

Orlando started the match well, getting into the final third and causing problems for the Red Bulls’ league-leading defense, but it was New York that had the first real chance of the afternoon in the 15th minute. Referee Ismail Elfath awarded the Red Bulls a penalty after Mohamed El-Munir and Bradley Wright-Phillips collided in the area.

Derrick Etienne stepped up to the spot but Adam Grinwis came up big to deny the Haitian international’s attempt. It would be New York’s only shot on frame in the first half.

The home side stepped up the pressure after the missed spot kick, with Wright-Phillips missing just wide of the post and Etienne skying a shot from the top of the area. Grinwis was called into action repeatedly, and time after time saved the day for City, though he only technically needed to make three saves in the match. The keeper pawed away a threatening cross that was eventually cleared out of danger and then took the ball off of BWP’s foot a few minutes later.

The Lions were content to sit back and absorb pressure as the first half wore on and frustrated the New York attack. Wright-Phillips was forced to the side due to an ankle issue following a collision with Tarek but managed to continue on.

The next golden opportunity came to Mueller. Shane O’Neill got forward and put a rocket of a shot on target, which was parried away by Luis Robles to the foot of Scott Sutter. Sutter’s cross found Mueller unmarked for a free header in the six-yard box but the rookie put his attempt over the bar.

Sean Davis had one final attempt in the first half but Schuler stepped up to make the stop and keep the match goalless entering halftime. Orlando held a very slight advantage in possession (50.9% to 49.1%) and both teams managed to take six shots each (one each on frame) before the break.

Kaku nearly put the home side in front after the restart after claiming the ball from Uri Rosell. The Paraguayan midfielder skipped by Schuler and took a shot from distance that landed just outside the far post. Kljestan responded well against his old team, putting a perfect ball behind the back line to Mueller, whose cross was stopped by Robles.

But it was Etienne finding redemption and the breakthrough for the home side in the 54th minute. The pacey forward sent O’Neill the wrong way and Grinwis couldn’t get a strong enough hand on the shot to keep it out of the net.

New York kept the pressure on as Michael Murillo was next to take a chance, but once again the Red Bull player couldn’t put a shot on target. Dom Dwyer thought he had found the equalizer in the 64th minute after his header found the back of the net, but the Orlando forward was correctly deemed offside by just a few inches. Dwyer had his third and final opportunity just minutes later, but his shot bounced just to the left of goal. City’s star striker made the Red Bull defense work hard all afternoon but Dom couldn’t quite capitalize.

Josué Colmán was O’Connor’s only substitute at the 70th minute mark, replacing Mueller after a performance where the rookie couldn’t take advantage of his chances in the final third. Chris Armas responded by bringing on center back Fidel Escobar to try to hold the lead.

Yoshimar Yotún earned a foul in a dangerous area at minute 77, but Kljestan’s attempt to spoil his former club’s afternoon went high and wide. Yotún once again led Orlando City in chances created, this time with two.

The Red Bulls continued to pile on the pressure even with the extra defender, spending most of the final minutes in Orlando’s end. Kaku and Wright-Phillips linked up for a potential score but the Englishman was denied by Grinwis once again in the 83rd minute.

Elfath added four minutes to the end of the match, and Orlando used almost all of it searching for the equalizer. Armas brought on Brian White to bleed the clock but the Lions put several dangerous balls into the area that New York neutralized.

The Red Bulls had another chance in the final minute of added time as Daniel Royer took a first-time shot. It was denied in the 94th minute by Grinwis, but New York wouldn’t need the insurance goal, however, as Elfath called for full time.

While Orlando took the possession lead in the second half and ended with 54% on the afternoon, the Lions couldn’t quite capitalize. City added just two more shots in the final 45 minutes and couldn’t put either on frame. The Red Bulls, meanwhile, ended the match with 13 shots and tested Grinwis much more in the second half.

In the end, it was a strong performance to close out the year from Orlando but City couldn’t put it all together to come away from Red Bull Arena with a result.


Orlando finishes the season in last place in the Eastern Conference and second from the bottom in the overall table. The Lions will have a lot of work to do in the upcoming off-season.

Lion Links

Lion Links: 3/21/25

Scott Sutter joins Orlando Pride staff, Pride watch party schedule announced, USMNT falls flat vs. Panama, and more.

Published

on

Carlos Romero, The Mane Land

Welcome to the weekend, Mane Landers. I just found out that Barbra Banda’s goal didn’t win NWSL Goal of the Week, despite earning the most fan votes. Utterly ridiculous and I hope that Banda takes out the supporters’ frustration this weekend. I need these upcoming matches to take the bad taste of that USMNT match out of my mouth. In the interest of moving on, let’s get to the links.

Former Lion Scott Sutter Joins Orlando Pride Staff

Former Orlando City fullback Scott Sutter has joined Seb Hines’ staff with the Orlando Pride. Sutter was one of three new support staffers announced by the Pride on Thursday and will serve in the role of player development coach. Sutter made 51 appearances with Orlando City in 2017 and 2018, scoring four goals and adding six assists in his time with the club. He joins fellow former Orlando City players Hines and Giles Barnes on the Pride’s staff. Previously, Sutter has coaching experience as a volunteer assistant coach at the University of Virginia and as an academy head coach with D.C. United. 

The Pride also named Erin Angelini as the new head of rehabilitation and Tara Kaff as the club’s performance nutritionist. In addition to the new hires, Chris Cafaro and Christi Edson were promoted to head of video performance analysis and head of performance, respectively.

Pride Announce Watch Party Schedule

You can watch the Orlando Pride away matches in the comfort of your own home, but if you crave the excitement of celebrating goals with your follow supporters, you can attend of the club’s official watch parties. These events are scheduled for some of the Pride’s biggest away matches against the best the NWSL has to offer. The match Sunday against NJ/NY Gotham FC is a must-see match and the first of those aforementioned watch parties.

Lifeless USMNT Crashes Out of Nations League

The USMNT lost 1-0 to Panama on a second-half stoppage-time goal from the visitors. The U.S. garnered most of the possession and more shots, but the Yanks couldn’t finish their chances and it came back to haunt them in the end. The loss knocks the U.S. out of the Concacaf Nations League, meaning it will be the first time that the competition isn’t won by the USMNT.

New Women’s World Sevens League

A new 7-v-7 league, Women’s World Sevens, will launch in May with a reported $5 million grand prize pool for each event. Eight clubs will participate in each event, though the participants have not yet been announced. We do know that form USWNT star Tobin Heath will be involved as a player advisor for the events.

Free Kicks


That will do it for today. Make sure to check back as we get you ready for the Orlando City and Orlando Pride matches this weekend. Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Orlando City

Orlando City’s Defense Must Start Rocking Right Now

Orlando City’s defensive struggles and the historical risks of giving up an average of more than two goals per game.

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

Rob Base and DJ E-Z Rock penned a song in 1988 that became a staple on dance floors and in sports arenas everywhere, and it will probably remain so for years to come. That song is the classic single “It Takes Two,” a favorite of mine for as long as I can remember. The reason I bring it up here is not because of Rob Base and his excellent flow, but rather because in three of the four games this season “it takes two” was also the answer to the question “how many goals will the Lions need to score to at least give themselves a chance to earn a point?”

Sadly, in the other game of the first four it was not it takes two but rather it takes two times two, or perhaps it it takes two two times, when the Lions gave up four goals in the season opener.

The regular season is 34 games long, and with only four games played, Orlando City still has 88% of its games remaining. And, with one win and one draw among those first four games, the Lions have earned four points, which is better than last season, when they had only earned one point after their first four games. That team went on to make it all the way to the Eastern Conference final, so we should not overreact to a slow start.

And really, the slow start is only on the defensive side, because the offense has scored nine goals, tying for second in MLS so far, and it is also among the top teams in shots (second), shots on target (third), goals per shot (seventh), and goals per shot on target (sixth).

I wanted to look a little more at the defense this week, and in particular look at that ugly stat around giving up at least two goals in every game. I looked back at the last three seasons in MLS to see how many regular-season games a team gave up at least two goals, and I was both heartened and disheartened by what I found. Here are the results, broken out by each team’s final position (reminder that the regular season is 34 games):

Final Position202220232024Three-Year Avg.
Champion11131914.3
Runner-Up4121410.0
Conf. Finalist14.010.013.512.5
Conf. Semi-Finalist13.012.313.813.0
Conf. Quarter-Finalist13.212.113.512.9
Wild CardN/A14.51916.8
Did Not Make Playoffs17.515.819.517.6

It was heartening to see that the average across every final position that ended in the playoffs was at least 10 games, and most were at least 12.5. I had thought it would be a lower average, so based on Orlando City’s early performances, I was glad to see that it was higher than I thought.

Though it is not in the chart above, the average for all playoff teams during the three seasons was 13.1 games of giving up at least two goals. That is approximately 38% of a season, so the average playoff team gave up at least two goals in nearly two out of every five games. This was also more than I thought, and it means that Orlando City can pretty quickly get back onto a similar pace with a good run of defensive form.

While I was happy to see that most teams — even teams that went deep into the playoffs — had posted double-digit games of shipping two or more goals, that still does not change the fact that Orlando City is on pace to give up two or more goals in…let me check my math here….every game this season. A four-game sample is a small one, and it would not be wise to make any firm conclusions off of that, but it is simple math to look at the three-year averages for the teams that went deep into the playoffs and to calculate that Orlando City is already around one-third of the way there, with nearly 90% of the season left to play. Disheartening.

The obvious question is why are the Lions giving up so many goals, and, as was discussed a bit on the most recent episode of The Mane Land PawedCast, the team has started four different defensive lineups in four games, and the Lions will make it five for five during this week’s game against D.C. United, as Pedro Gallese was called up to Peru’s national team, so Javier Otero will likely be the starter in goal. The back line in front of Otero will probably be a repeat of a lineup that has already been used, but the lack of continuity in defense has certainly contributed to some of the issues in the first four games.

Head Coach Óscar Pareja has pointed to individual mistakes that need to be cleaned up for the results to improve, but the team as a whole has allowed the fourth-most shots on target this season, an average of 5.75 per game. Using expected goals as a measure for the danger of the locations of the shots allowed, Orlando City is giving up shots from the second-most dangerous locations across MLS, making it unsurprising that its opponents have put so many shots on target per game and converted 10 of those shots into goals. Individual mistakes certainly contributed, and Robin Jansson was called for a questionable foul that gave the Red Bulls an undeserved penalty kick, but the issues seem to be a little deeper than just a few mistakes that need to be cleaned up.

Or, perhaps it is a few individual mistakes, a lack of continuity on the back line and also some bad luck. Six of the goals allowed have been from within four yards, one was a penalty kick, and one was shot into a wide open goal after Rodrigo Schlegel took perhaps the worst touch in his professional career. According to Opta’s tracking, Orlando City only gave up five goals from four yards or closer in 2024, and for that number to already be six this season seems like an aberration more than a new normal. The team also opened the season against Philadelphia, and after four games played, the Union lead the league in goals scored. That was also the game when Jansson was unexpectedly scratched from the starting lineup just minutes before the opening kickoff, changing the defensive game plan considerably.

Maybe that is me seeing the glass half full instead of half empty, but these are the same defensive players as last season, with the exception of Alex Freeman playing instead of Dagur Dan Thórhallsson for most of the minutes at right back. The defensive statistics were much better in 2024 than thus far in 2025, and Freeman is not a downgrade from Thórhallsson, so I think a positive regression to the mean will be coming. The 2024 team also gave up 10 goals in the first four games, 2.5 goals per game, but then gave up 40 goals in the next 30 regular-season games, a reduction of more than one goal per game, from 2.5 to 1.33.

The Lions’ defense has the talent and the experience to do something similar this year, especially as the players spend more minutes together, and there is no time like the present to have their first game of giving up fewer than two goals. I do not think it is too much to ask, and if the players are looking for some inspiration, they could get that by watching the Orlando Pride’s defensive players, who are coached by former Orlando City defender Seb Hines.

Let’s hope that the defense can, to quote Rob Base, make this thing go right.

Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Orlando City

Orlando City vs. D.C. United: Three Keys to Victory

What do the Lions need to do to secure three points at home against D.C. United?

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City B

Orlando City returns to Inter&Co Stadium Saturday night to face Eastern Conference foe D.C. United. The Lions have given up a ton of goals this season but have also scored quite a few. However, with only one win so far, Orlando City needs to get a positive result at home this weekend. Here’s what Orlando City needs to do to earn all three points against D.C. United.

Blank Benteke

D.C. United has scored six goals so far this season. Christian Benteke has scored three of those six goals. While that is completely unsurprising, it also makes Benteke the most important player on the field for the Lions to shut down. Orlando City has given up at least two goals in every match and a total of 10 goals already this season. That must change on Saturday night.

Robin Jansson is back in the starting lineup, but he didn’t have his best match against the New York Red Bulls. We need the Beefy Swede to get back into form both mentally and physically if he is to help keep Benteke off the scoresheet. Obviously, Jansson won’t be the only player needed to stop Benteke, but he is the leader of the team and the leader of the defense.

The other major factor is Pedro Gallese’s absence, as the keeper will be on international duty. That means Javier Otero will get his first MLS start in goal. Otero will need to rise to the challenge in front of a leaky back line. Said back line needs to stop being so leaky to help out Otero. Everyone elevating to get the job done is ideal.

Continued DP Contributions

Orlando City’s Designated Players have scored six of the club’s nine goals, and provided four of the team’s five assists on the season. While that is exactly like it should be for any team, that hasn’t always been the case for the Lions in the past. It’s so normal and also so odd at the same time.

D.C. United has given up five goals so far this season, which is pretty average in comparison around the league. My point is that Kim Jun-hong is not Carlos Coronel, and D.C. United’s defense hasn’t been as stingy as the New York Red Bulls defense. If the Lions can score two goals against New York — and it should have been more — then Marco Pasalic, Martin Ojeda, and Luis Muriel can certainly score multiple goals against D.C.

New Midfield, Who Dis?

Eduard Atuesta had an excellent game against the New York Red Bulls. Joran Gerbet had as good a first start as any rookie could in place of Cesar Araujo, who missed the match due to some tightness late in the week. Orlando City may have its starting defensive midfielder back, but if not, then Gerbet will need to build on his performance from last week.

The D.C. United midfielders are expected to provide service for Benteke. The Orlando City midfield needs to disrupt that service at every opportunity. If they do this, then Atuesta can do what he does best to link the defense to the Orlando City offense and provide opportunities to the attack to hopefully outscore D.C. United.


That is what I will be looking for Saturday night. Let me know your thoughts in the comments below. Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Trending