Orlando City
Orlando City vs. Toronto FC: Player Grades and Man of the Match
Orlando City extended its unbeaten streak to six matches after winning 1-0 over Toronto FC. Tesho Akindele scored in the 12th minute and the defense continued its dominant form despite injuries. Here is how each individual Lion performed in the win, as well as who earned the title of Man of the Match.
Starters
GK, Pedro Gallese, 7.5 (MotM) — The Peruvian goalkeeper secured his fourth clean sheet of the season, already surpassing his total from a shortened 2020 season. It was a busy night for El Pulpo, making five saves throughout the match, including a pair late in stoppage time to put the game on ice. Gallese also had a great save in the first half after a shot was deflected while he was already motioning to his left. In what couldn’t have been more than a second, he readjusted for a kick save to send the ball out of harm’s way. He was beaten by a terrific chipped touch by Yeferson Soteldo in the first half, but his defense was there to keep Toronto from scoring. As usual, Gallese was confident and calm when the game was on the line. He’s our Man of the Match for making difficult saves and standing tall in the game’s biggest moments.
D, Kyle Smith, 6 — With neither Ruan nor João Moutinho on the roster as they’re being eased back into things, Smith played at right back. He struggled to deal with Soteldo, who wreaked havoc all night long on Smith’s side of the field. That being said, Smith wasn’t terrible defensively by any means as he led the team with a whopping nine tackles. He also had two interceptions and a clearance. On offense, his one shot was on target but gobbled up by Toronto goalkeeper Alex Bono. He had three crosses but none found their target. Smith played every minute of the match with 63 touches, but only had 27 passes at a 78% success rate. Although he didn’t have a key pass, Smith delivered a great ball down the right side to Silvester van der Water in the play that led to Orlando’s goal for a secondary, or “hockey,” assist.
D, Antonio Carlos, 7 — It was up to Carlos to put out the fires when Soteldo or other attackers came charging into the box. The Brazilian did just that, leading the Lions with six clearances to snuff out Toronto’s chances. Carlos also had a tackle and three interceptions to help ensure Orlando’s clean sheet. He continues to be the target on set pieces and nearly scored on a corner kick but his headed effort went just over the crossbar. That area of his game seems to be improving and is something to watch for moving forward. Carlos finished with 61 touches and completed 83% of his 47 passes to help build out of the back.
D, Robin Jansson, 7 — In his first start of the season, Jansson’s biggest moment on defense came in the 32nd minute when he stopped Soteldo’s attempt after the winger got past Carlos and Gallese. With Carlos often drifting over to help Smith, Jansson had to be the backbone of Orlando’s defense and did well in that role. He also pitched in offensively with a key pass in the 67th minute to give Akindele a chance to double Orlando’s lead. In his return to the starting lineup, Jansson had a tackle, two interceptions, two clearances, 60 touches, and 53 passes at an 81% success rate.
D, Rodrigo Schlegel, 6.5 — After doing a great job as center back for the first five games this season, Schlegel was moved to left back and continued to impress. He had a tough assignment against former Lion Richie Laryea and was definitely scorched on occasion. In the 71st minute, Jacob Shaffelburg raced around Gallese to shoot from a tough angle and it looked like the ball would trickle into the back of the net. But Schlegel was there to cover for his goalkeeper, running back and getting in position to make a clearance on the goal line. Schlegel finished second on the team in both touches (79) and passes (59 at an 80% rate). Defensively, he had a tackles three interceptions, and a clearance. Schlegel showed his versatility by moving to left back and preventing Laryea from abusing the right wing.
MF, Sebas Mendez, 6.5 — The Ecuadorian midfielder had another great outing in his sixth-straight start this season. Mendez went the distance yet again, playing every minute and leading the Lions with 86 touches and 65 passes at a great 95% rate. He was a force defensively as well, racking up five tackles, three interceptions, and three clearances as he helped out all over the field. Mendez didn’t have any shots or key passes, but it was still a solid performance.
MF, Junior Urso, 6 — The Bear may have only had 50 touches in this one, but he put most of them to good use. Urso played all 90 minutes and had one shot that went into the stands, a key pass, three clearances, two interceptions, and blocked shot a shot from Jozy Altidore. It wasn’t his best night as he mostly dueled with Michael Bradley in the midfield, but he did help keep Altidore quiet by clogging up lanes in the midfield. Urso was dispossessed twice and only completed 23 of his 31 passes.
MF, Silvester van der Water, 6.5 — The Dutchman had an assist in his first start as a Lion. After rushing down a great ball by Smith, the winger cut back and then whipped the ball in with his left foot to serve Akindele the ball on a silver platter for his only cross of the match. Van der Water plays with a clear hunger to score goals, leading the team alongside Akindele with three shots, although only one was on target. Using quick bursts of speed to suddenly change direction or chase down the ball, he’s a dynamic player and showed plenty to be excited about in the future. In 58 minutes of action, van der Water had 28 touches, two tackles, a successful dribble, and completed 10 of his 13 passes.
MF, Mauricio Pereyra, 6 — With Nani suspended, it was up to Pereyra to create chances for the Lions. Pereyra was great at stringing passes together on offense and had two key passes. In the first few minutes of the second half, Carlos found him in open space and in a moment he sent the ball forward to give Akindele a golden opportunity to score that was squandered. But for most of the night, Toronto was all over Pereyra. He was dispossessed three times and had 46 passes at a 76% rate. Neither of his two crosses in open play found their target, but he was successful on two of his five crosses from set pieces. In 87 minutes on the field, Pereyra had 63 touches as he often had to become an outlet for Lions to get out of trouble.
MF, Chris Mueller, 6 — It was a tough night for Mueller, but mainly because he was dueling with former Lion Richie Laryea for most of it. Although he didn’t have any crosses or shots, Mueller showcased incredible vision on the left side of the pitch and led the team with three key passes. His best was in the 30th minute when he found van der Water in open space, but the shot went right at Bono. Mueller’s biggest issue remains dribbling into trouble as he was only successful on one of his five attempted dribbles. Mueller pitched in on defense with an interception and two clearances, often tracking back to help out. He completed 26 of his 29 passes and had 42 touches in a 70 minute shift.
F, Tesho Akindele, 6.5 — The Canadian scored his second goal of the season, getting his head on the end of van der Water’s cross to give Orlando an early lead. Akindele had another chance at the start of the second half after Pereyra sent him in on goal with only Alex Bono to beat, but his shot went wide. He had a similar opportunity later on, but just couldn’t get enough on his shot as he was closed down from behind at the last second. With Alexandre Pato injured and Daryl Dike on loan, Akindele has been under a bit of a microscope this season. He definitely had opportunities to put the game out of reach, but that shouldn’t overshadow him scoring the game’s only goal and keeping the pressure on Toronto. Akindele finished with three shots (two on target), 31 touches, and 24 passes at a 79% success rate.
Substitutes
MF, Andres Perea (58’), 6 — Coming on for van der Water, Perea did well solidifying the midfield to help Smith on the right side. He had 14 touches, two dribbles, completed eight of his nine passes. He also had a key pass, using his vision to send the ball to Benji Michel in a perfect spot to score. His versatility continues to matter as he’s able to come on and fulfill whatever role is needed of him in the midfield.
F, Benji Michel (69’), 6 — Michel nearly scored in the 84th minute. Perea put the ball in open space for him to run down and he took a great first touch with his chest to then shoot with his left foot. Bono managed to make a good save to keep Michel off the scoresheet, but it was nice seeing him make a familiar impact as a substitute. He had 11 touches and was successful on all six of his passes.
MF, Joey DeZart (85’), N/A — It was another late cameo for DeZart and there wasn’t enough shown in his brief appearance to warrant a grade. Regardless, DeZart did well late in the match to break up plays, including chasing down Ayo Akinola in a dangerous position. Throughout all six minutes of stoppage time, DeZart was there, working hard.
MF, Alexander Alvarado (85’), N/A — It was Alvarado’s first appearance since the season-opener and he was the epitome of fresh legs. The Ecuadorian kept plays alive on the wing, had a clearance on a set piece, and made a crucial block to end the game. With Nani out again next week, it will be interesting to see if he will get more minutes after a decent outing in this one.
That’s how I saw the individual performances of the Lions in this game. Let us know what you thought about the players and don’t forget to vote for your Man of the Match.
Polling Closed
| Player | Votes |
| Pedro Gallese | 62 |
| Antonio Carlos | 10 |
| Robin Jansson | 5 |
| SIlvester van der Water | 22 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | 2 |
| Sebas Mendez | 7 |
| Other | 2 |
Orlando City
Orlando City vs. CF Montreal: Final Score 1-1 as Lions Drop More Points at Home
The Lions made three-win Montreal look like a competent team in a wasteful effort at home.
Orlando City couldn’t make Martin Ojeda’s goal in the first half stand up as a late Montreal penalty kick sent the Lions to their third straight game without a win in a disappointing 1-1 draw at Inter&Co Stadium. Rodrigo Schlegel’s foul on Prince Owusu allowed the latter to tie the match from the spot late in a game in which Montreal (3-13-6, 15 points) finished with only four shots and just the one on target.
The Lions (9-5-8, 35 points) themselves mustered just 11 shots and put three on goal against the worst team in the Eastern Conference, which was playing on short rest after a home match in the Canadian Championship at midweek. The season series ended with two draws, which doesn’t speak well of an Orlando side with postseason aspirations.
“We couldn’t reach the rhythm the whole game,” Orlando City Head Coach Oscar Pareja said after the match. “I have to say that we tried to move and eventually we had some actions that ignited us a little, but the overall (thought) was it was a very uncomfortable game for us. The effort was there. It was a very complicated game. It was not an easy one.”
Pareja had to juggle his lineup a bit because of a pair of suspensions for yellow card accumulation to Pedro Gallese and Robin Jansson. Javier Otero started in goal behind a back line of Rafael Santos, Schlegel, David Brekalo, and Alex Freeman — his first game back since the Gold Cup ended. Cesar Araujo and Eduard Atuesta started in central midfield between wingers Ojeda and Marco Pasalic, with Luis Muriel and Ramiro Enrique up top.
The first half began as a choppy and dull as any game this season, as Montreal kept much of the ball early with neither side able to create much of a threat. The visitors won a free kick in the 10th minute but didn’t do anything with it, but aside from that, the opening 15 minutes were quiet.
Orlando City finally attempted a shot in the 17th minute, but Ojeda got well under his volley attempt off a deflected cross and sent his attempt high into The Wall.
It wasn’t until the 24th minute when the game saw its first shot on target. Muriel fired a left-footed effort from just outside the area, but Jonathan Sirois was able to dive to his left to make the save. Three minutes later, the Lions broke the scoreless deadlock on a set piece.
Samuel Piette fouled Pasalic just outside the area in the 27th minute. Ojeda and Muriel lined up over it, with Ojeda tapping it to the Colombian forward. Muriel put his foot on the ball to stop it, teeing it up for the Argentine to blast just inside the right post to make it 1-0 in the 28th minute. It was Ojeda’s 10th goal of the MLS season, making him the third Lion to record 10 goals and 10 assists in a season (all competitions). It was also his seventh consecutive MLS match with a goal contribution, setting a new club record.
“It’s something we work on with the coaches. Martin Perelman is in charge of that in particular,” Ojeda said. “Today was a bit of (guile) that thankfully ended in a goal. We do have quality players with a lot of technique. A lot of these plays can result in things like this, so yeah, let’s continue on this way.”
Montreal’s only shot attempt of the half came shortly after Ojeda’s goal. Hennadii Synchuk tried to catch Otero napping, blasting a shot from distance that didn’t miss the right post by much, sending it just wide.
Ojeda scored a minute later, but the flag came up for offside. Enrique had played him in with a lovely through ball, but replay showed Ojeda was just off and the call on the field was confirmed after video review.
Five minutes later, Montreal followed suit. Ojeda and Santos tried to work a give-and-go up the left sideline, but it didn’t come off and the visitors broke in transition. Owusu got onto a through ball and beat Otero, but he was several yards offside and it was an easy offside call.
Pasalic drew another free kick early in stoppage time from the left. Ojeda scorched a cross to the back post for Brekalo, but the Slovenian couldn’t get his header on target. Orlando won one more late free kick near the touchline and Muriel sent it in. Enrique had a free header, but his redirect was right at Sirois on the last touch of the half.
At the break, Orlando held the advantage in possession (51.8%-48.2%), shots (6-1), and shots on target (3-0). Montreal had more corners (1-0) and better passing accuracy (91.1%-90.9%).
“When you find rivals that have that model of chasing and converting the game into dueling in every single area, it has that tendency to be a game that is caught here and there, that the sequences are broken if we cannot get the flow that we want,” Pareja said of the team’s disjointed attack tonight. “And eventually we did it. It seemed like we were getting the rhythm and immediately we came back to that discomfort in the game.”
Montreal came out of the lockerroom with a bit more urgency than Orlando for the first few minutes, keeping the Lions pinned back. When Orlando finally held some possession, Freeman found some space down the left, cut inside, and sent a left-footed shot over the crossbar in the 50th minute.
Montreal then won a series of free kicks in the attacking third. Although the visitors didn’t pay any of them off, they came close in the 55th minute when an entry ball hit someone in front of Otero and fell in the box. Schlegel swooped in and cleared the danger.
The Lions won their first corner of the game in the 58th minute but played it short and were flagged for offside on the play.
The game kind of went dead in terms of chances for a while after that. Ivan Angulo’s blocked effort in the 73rd was the closest either side came to scoring over a 15-minute span.
Montreal got its gift in the 81st minute. Owusu carried the ball into the area on the left and went down after contact with Schlegel. The Montreal forward went looking for the contact and sold it well, with Ramy Touchan pointing to the spot. Owusu then used a stutter step to get Otero leaning and slotted home to tie the game in the 83rd minute.
“We are tired of seeing that, and it’s really frustrating,” Pareja said of the penalty decision going against Orlando. “It’s a big dive.”
Orlando City didn’t create much down the stretch. Ojeda fired from the top of the box but missed just wide in the 86th minute. Freeman cut inside and had his shot blocked early in stoppage time. Second-half sub Nico Rodriguez tried from distance moments later and the ball deflected off a defender and changed directions, but it stayed in the middle for Sirois to save in the fifth of the eight added minutes.
The Lions finished with the advantage in possession (52.9%-47.1%), shots (11-4), shots on target (3-1), corners (3-2), and passing accuracy (90.1%-90%).
With the draw, Orlando City is winless in three straight games (0-1-2) and winless in its last three at home (0-2-1).
“I think they kept the ball, which, you know, good defense is a good offense, and keeping the ball and limiting our chances in the attack,” said Kyle Smith, who subbed on in the second half to make his 200th appearance across all competitions for Orlando. “And then I think with their back five, it helps control what we were trying to do.”
“The team confidence has to stay alive the whole year,” Pareja said. “I don’t consider that we have to depend to the results. Our work and our job and our professionalism tell us that when the game finishes, you have to move on to the next one. We know that it hurts, but we have to be capable to move on. Tomorrow we have the responsibility to prepare for this game on Wednesday. That is a big challenge as well.”
The Lions have a quick turnaround as they look to bounce back when New York City FC visits Inter&Co Stadium on Wednesday.
Orlando City
Orlando City vs. CF Montreal: Preview, How to Watch, TV Info, Live Stream, Lineups, Match Thread, and More
The shorthanded Lions look to get back in the win column when Montreal visits.
Welcome to your match thread for a Saturday night matchup between Orlando City (9-5-7, 34 points) and CF Montreal (3-13-5, 14 points) at Inter&Co Stadium (7:30 p.m., MLS Season Pass on Apple TV). It’s the second of the two scheduled meetings between the Eastern Conference rivals in 2025.
Here’s what you need to know ahead of the match.
History
The Lions are 8-9-6 against Montreal in the all-time regular-season series and 10-10-6 in all competitions since they joined MLS. OCSC is 4-4-3 in home MLS games against Montreal and 6-4-3 in matchups held in the greater Orlando area — this includes wins in Leagues Cup and the MLS is Back Tournament knockout rounds.
The most recent meeting was a scoreless draw in Montreal on April 19. The Lions’ efforts at bringing home a road win took a hit in the second half when Rafael Santos was sent off.
The teams last met in Orlando in the 2024 Leagues Cup competition nearly one year ago on July 26, with the Lions running rampant in a 4-1 home victory. Dagur Dan Thorhallsson, Facundo Torres, Ramiro Enrique, and Martin Ojeda staked Orlando to a 4-0 lead. Josef Martinez scored for Montreal, although his bid for a brace was denied when Pedro Gallese stopped his penalty kick attempt.
The two sides met in Montreal on April 20, 2024 trading goals back and forth in a 2-2 draw at Stade Saputo. Mason Toye opened the scoring early, but Torres equalized from the spot a few minutes later. Ariel Lassiter appeared to win it late in normal time for the hosts, but Ivan Angulo struck in stoppage time to earn Orlando City a road point. These teams opened the 2024 season against each other in Orlando and played to a 0-0 draw. The Lions dominated the stat sheet but had a goal waved off for offside and simply weren’t lethal enough.
The teams met twice in 2023, completing the season series on Sept. 30, 2023, with Orlando winning 3-0 in dominant fashion. Jonathan Sirois’ own goal opened the scoring, and Thorhallsson and Torres added strikes for Orlando City. That was a good measure of revenge for OCSC, after Montreal defeated Orlando City 2-0 and handed the Lions their first road loss of the 2023 MLS season on May 6 at Stade Saputo. A Robin Jansson own goal got Montreal started in the second half and Romell Quioto added a second goal four minutes later.
These two sides played their biggest game against each other in the 2022 MLS playoffs, with CF Montreal knocking Orlando City out of the postseason by a 2-0 scoreline on Oct. 16, with goals by Ismael Kone and Djordje Mihailovic — the latter coming deep in stoppage time from the penalty spot.
Each team won at home in the two-game, regular-season series in 2022, with Montreal thumping Orlando 4-1 on May 7. Joel Waterman, Mihailovic, Joaquin Torres, and Zachary Brault-Guillard did the damage on the scoreboard and Orlando City managed just two shot attempts, with Joao Moutinho’s goal on a set piece helping the Lions avoid a shutout. Orlando City did not have either starting center back for that match, and it showed. The teams also met on opening day of the 2022 season, when Orlando City captured a 2-0 home win behind second-half goals from Alexandre Pato and Benji Michel.
In 2021, the teams met in Montreal on Decision Day, with the Lions earning a 2-0 road victory at Stade Saputo to clinch a playoff spot. Sebas Mendez and Daryl Dike provided the goals. That season’s matchup in Orlando came on Oct. 20, 2021, with the visitors managing a 1-1 draw. Chris Mueller struck for the Lions just before halftime, but Rudy Camacho answered on a corner kick header shortly after the restart. The first meeting of 2021 took place Sept. 15 in Orlando with the Lions falling 4-2 and finishing the game with just nine men after both Nani and Andres Perea were sent off. Quioto led Montreal with a goal and two assists. Mathieu Choiniere and Quioto put Montreal up 2-0, but despite already being down one man, Jansson and Ruan tied things up. The visitors got two more from Lassi Lappalainen and Sunusi Ibrahim.
The teams met at Red Bull Arena in late 2020 as the team then known as the Montreal Impact played home games in New Jersey due to the pandemic. Orlando City got a Dike goal in the 39th minute to win 1-0 on Nov. 1, 2020. It was the second meeting of the 2020 season, with Orlando also beating Montreal 1-0 in the MLS is Back Tournament knockout rounds on July 25 to advance to the quarterfinals. Tesho Akindele scored the game’s only goal on a Montreal defensive mistake.
Orlando City snapped a six-game winless streak against Montreal (0-5-1) in MLS regular-season play dating back to 2016 when the Lions put the Impact to the sword in a 3-0 drubbing at Stade Saputo on June 1, 2019. Nani (penalty), Akindele, and Will Johnson supplied the offense that day. The Lions fell 3-1 at Exploria Stadium back on March 16, 2019, and Ignacio Piatti was a big reason why, scoring his ninth and 10th career goals against Orlando, adding to a strike by Orji Okwonkwo. Dom Dwyer added a cosmetic goal late for Orlando City to spoil the clean sheet.
Montreal did not allow a goal against the Lions in 2018, sweeping the two-game set from Orlando, and the Impact shut out Orlando City in three of the six meetings in that 5-0-1 run. The lone draw in that time frame was a 3-3 shootout in Orlando in 2017, in which the Impact led deep in stoppage time, only to see Jonathan Spector’s well-placed header steal the Lions a point.
Orlando won the first two meetings in 2016 by a combined score of 6-2. The teams split three meetings in 2015, with each going 1-1-1.
Overview
Orlando City enters this match on a two-game winless streak after a 2-2 come-from-behind road draw at Charlotte FC a week ago. The Lions enter having given up two goals in each of the last three matches — six in all — and things aren’t set up for success tonight with both Jansson and Gallese suspended for yellow card accumulation. Orlando City is 5-3-2 in home matches this season, however two of those three losses have come in the team’s last two games in Inter&Co Stadium. In order to stop that skid, the Lions will have to tighten up the defense. If he starts in his first match since the end of the Concacaf Gold Cup, Alex Freeman’s return could help.
Montreal is last in the Eastern Conference with just three wins and 14 points this season. But it bears repeating that one of those points came at Orlando’s expense. Additionally, two of Montreal’s three wins on the season have come in the past four MLS matches. Add in that two of the club’s three victories have been road wins (2-7-2), and tonight’s visitors may be feeling a bit more confident than they’ve shown for much of this season. CF Montreal did, however, play a midweek match at home, finishing in a 2-2 draw against Forge FC in Canadian Championship action.
To get the win tonight, Orlando will have to get back to playing sound defense. If the Lions can stay organized, they can get out in transition where Marco Pasalic, Enrique, and Ojeda can be dangerous.
“It is part of our DNA that we don’t play with any context of the teams — not how they’re doing in the standings or how they are doing at the moment. It’s something that is not our problem,” Orlando City Head Coach Oscar Pareja said ahead of the match. “If we play against another team that is really bright, we don’t care either. It’s first about trying to be ourselves while trying to get the initiative and plan the game model — trying to do our things the way we plan it, with the energy that our fans deserve. The respect that we have for not just the game but for the jersey — all of those things don’t change, regardless of the moment or the opposition. The only way I know how to win games in my life is to take it the best way possible on Saturday at 7:30.”
Orlando City will be without Jansson (suspension), Gallese (suspension), Joran Gerbet (thigh), Duncan McGuire (shoulder), Wilder Cartagena (Achilles), and Yutaro Tsukada (knee). Per Montreal’s game notes, every player is available. Montreal will be without Jalen Neal (ankle), while Samuel Piette (illness) and Giacomo Vrioni (elbow) are questionable.
Match Content
- Our most recent episode of The Mane Land PawedCast features our key match-ups and score predictions for tonight’s game.
- Our David Rohe provided his three keys to an Orlando City victory over Montreal.
Official Lineups:
Orlando City (4-4-2)
Goalkeeper: Javier Otero.
Defenders: Rafael Santos, Rodrigo Schlegel, David Brekalo, Alex Freeman.
Midfielders: Martin Ojeda, Eduard Atuesta, Cesar Araujo, Marco Pasalic.
Forwards: Luis Muriel, Ramiro Enrique.
Bench: Carlos Mercado, Kyle Smith, Zakaria Taifi, Thomas Williams, Colin Guske, Dagur Dan Thorhallsson, Ivan Angulo, Nico Rodriguez, Shak Mohammed.
CF Montreal (4-3-3)
Goalkeeper: Jonathan Sirois.
Defenders: Luca Petrasso, Brendan Craig, Fernando Alvarez, Dawid Bugaj.
Midfielders: Joel Waterman, Victor Loturi, Samuel Piette.
Forwards: Caden Clark, Prince Owusu, Hennadii Synchuk.
Bench: Sebastian Breza, Aleksandr Guboglo, Tom Pearce, Owen Graham-Roache, Olger Escobar, Fabian Herbers, Bryce Duke, Dante Sealy, Sunusi Ibrahim.
Referees:
Ref: Ramy Touchan.
AR1: Jeremy Kieso.
AR2: Rhett Hammil.
4th: Natalie Simon.
VAR: Shawn Tehini.
AVAR: Joshua Patlak.
How to Watch
Match Time: 7:30 p.m.
Venue: Inter&Co Stadium — Orlando.
TV/Live Stream: MLS Season Pass on Apple TV.
Radio: AM 810 FOX Sports Radio Orlando (English); Mega 97.1 FM (Spanish).
Social Media: For rapid reaction and live updates, follow us on Bluesky Social at @themaneland.bsky.social or follow Orlando City’s official Twitter (@OrlandoCitySC) or Bluesky (@OrlandoCitySC) feed.
Enjoy the match. Go City!
Orlando City
Orlando City Nailed the Signing of Eduard Atuesta
Orlando City spent big to sign the Colombian midfielder, and so far the decision looks like a great one.
There was a lot of understandable hand-wringing among Orlando City fans when Wilder Cartagena went down with a ruptured Achilles tendon in preseason. The injury meant that the Lions would be without one of their most important players for the 2025 season, as Cartagena and Cesar Araujo had formed an excellent partnership in the engine room of Orlando’s squad. Fans needn’t have worried though, because the front office quickly identified Eduard Atuesta as the man it wanted to replace Cartagena and persevered through some public back-and-forth to land him from Palmeiras.
Not only did OCSC sign a proven MLS-caliber midfielder, but the Colombian assimilated into the team almost immediately and has been just as good as advertised.
For one, he’s been able to provide a consistent impact on the defensive side of things. Atuesta has made 15 regular-season appearances (13 starts) and has logged 1,172 minutes on the field. In that time, he’s recorded 22 tackles (tied for fifth on the team), 10 interceptions (tied for fourth), and 14 blocks (eighth). Out of he and Araujo, the Uruguayan is asked to do more of the defensive work, but Atuesta has still been a perfectly capable contributor on that side of the ball.
His impact has most been felt on offense though. We knew when the signing was announced that Atuesta should carry more punch going forward than Cartagena did, and that’s precisely how things have played out. His six assists is second most on the team, trailing only Martin Ojeda, who has nine. He also has the second-most progressive passes on the team with 92, again only behind Ojeda, who has 104. If that isn’t enough, consider that despite playing in defensive midfield, he’s third on the team in shot-creating actions with 65 (trailing Ojeda with 108, and Luis Muriel with 73), and he leads the team in goal-creating actions with 13. In fact, those 13 goal-creating actions are tied for the fifth most in the league, and his average of one goal-creating action per 90 minutes is third best in the league behind Lionel Messi and Ali Ahmed who average 1.25 and 1.04, respectively.
Really, the only area where his game is lacking on offense is scoring actual goals, as he has yet to get one in MLS play, despite having some good chances to do so. Despite the lack of direct goals, he’s become instrumental in Orlando being able to operate its offense at a high level — just cast your mind back to earlier in the year, when the Lions played to multiple scoreless draws when he was unavailable due to injury. OCSC eventually got its offense looking better in his absence due to Joran Gerbet growing more comfortable and the Designated Players getting back on track, but that took time, and the Lions just look much more cohesive when he’s on the field than when he isn’t. Those 92 progressive passes are an extremely important reason why, as he and Araujo (who has 84) are vital when it comes to joining the defense to the attack.
He’s also costing Orlando a reasonable amount of money for what the club is getting in return. His $725,000 in guaranteed compensation makes him the seventh-highest-paid player on the team, but so far he’s holding up his end of the bargain with what he’s bringing to the offense. That number places him 22nd among central midfielders in the league behind guys like Felipe Carballo ($1,199,777.00 in guaranteed compensation for two assists in 16 appearances), Mateusz Klich ($1,937,338.00 in guaranteed compensation for one assist in 16 appearances), and Sebastian Lletget ($891,250.00 in guaranteed compensation for one goal and one assist in 11 appearances). While those guys don’t all exactly match the profile of Atuesta, the point I’m making is that so far he’s been pretty good value for money when you look around at what some other teams in the league are getting.
His impact is perhaps best summarized by Fbref.com’s scouting report tool, which compares someone to other players in his position over the course of the last 365 days. While this isn’t a perfect tool for evaluating Atuesta as an Orlando City player, since it takes into account some of his stats while he was with Palmeiras, it still provides a useful look at his current level, and this is just exactly what you want to see.
In short, I can’t give the front office enough credit for landing Atuesta. The club didn’t try to cheaply replace the vastly important Cartagena and instead identified the guy the Lions wanted, went out, and made the signing happen. So far, that decision has paid off — most notably in what the Colombian midfielder has brought to Orlando City’s offense. If he keeps assisting at his current rate and also starts scoring a few goals of his own, then his signing could end up being one of the best pieces of business in recent years. Vamos Orlando!
Orlando City vs. CF Montreal: Final Score 1-1 as Lions Drop More Points at Home
Orlando City vs. CF Montreal: Preview, How to Watch, TV Info, Live Stream, Lineups, Match Thread, and More
Orlando City Nailed the Signing of Eduard Atuesta
-
Orlando City2 weeks agoOrlando City vs. FC Cincinnati: Final Score 2-1 as Lions Fall at Home Again
-
Orlando City2 weeks agoOrlando City vs. FC Cincinnati: Player Grades and Man of the Match
-
Orlando City1 week agoOrlando City vs. Charlotte FC: Preview, How to Watch, TV Info, Live Stream, Lineups, Match Thread, and More
-
Orlando City2 weeks agoOrlando City vs. FC Cincinnati: Five Takeaways
-
Orlando City1 week agoOrlando City vs. Charlotte FC: Final Score 2-2 as Lions Erase Late Two-Goal Deficit
-
Orlando City2 weeks agoOrlando City vs. FC Cincinnati: Preview, How to Watch, TV Info, Live Stream, Lineups, Match Thread, and More
-
Opinion1 week agoPredicting Orlando City’s July Results
-
Orlando City3 days agoOrlando City vs.CF Montreal: Three Keys to Victory