Connect with us

Opinion

Preseason Orlando City Position Battles: Right Back

Who has the edge at right back prior to the start of the year?

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Jeremy Reper

Preseason preparations are in full swing as the start of the Major League Soccer regular season is a mere 36 days away, and Orlando City’s first match to be played against Cavalry FC is just three days before that on Feb. 21. Players reported to training camp earlier in the week after completing preseason physicals and have begun working and training under the coaching staff in the hopes of cracking the starting 11 for the opening day match. A good majority of the roster already seems set in stone based upon returning players and off-season signings, but the right back position is one which may be up for grabs and is the role I am going to break down today.

Last year, two players — Michael Halliday and Dagur Dan Thorhallsson — both logged significant minutes at right back, with the former logging significant playing time and appearances in the starting lineup during the first third of the 2023 season and the latter assuming the role throughout the summer and playoff push. Both players contributed from the right flank in 2023 and bring different advantages and disadvantages to a starting lineup that looks to keep its outside backs engaged as a critical part of the game plan.

The Homegrown

Michael Halliday signed a Homegrown Player contract with Orlando City on July 15, 2020 and was an OCB standout for a year before joining the first team in 2021. Halliday found himself behind former starter Ruan, who was firmly entrenched as the agent of chaos on the right side, but Halliday consistently improved on the training grounds and earned a starting spot to start the 2023 season. In 2023, Halliday appeared in 18 matches and logged nine starts before a summertime injury, a prolonged rehab period, and international duty took him out of the lineup. In 847 minutes, he logged two assists, completed 76.7% of his passing attempts and tallied 20 tackles, 26 clearances, and nine interceptions. Halliday also appeared in both matches against Liga MX giants Tigres, holding his own against some of the best competition that Orlando has faced in club history.

The Icelandic

Dagur Dan Thorhallsson was signed almost a year ago on Jan. 31, 2023, making his way to MLS via Breidablik in Iceland’s top flight. In the first half of his inaugural season in the City Beautiful, the majority of his appearances on the pitch came in a reserve role, although he did log three starts across the first full month of matches back in March of 2023. It wasn’t truly until the MLS regular season resumed after the Leagues Cup competition that Thorhallsson ascended into a new role as starting right back. Initially billed as a midfielder, there were some growing pains to adjust to a new position, but as the season wound down, Thorhallsson’s presence and, more importantly, chemistry with his teammates was a strong factor in Orlando’s superb run of form to see out the 2023 season.

Thorhallsson finished the season with 30 appearances and 12 starts while logging 1,195 minutes. He contributed three assists and two goals on the year while completing 88% of his passing attempts. Defensively, as Thorhallsson grew into his position, opponents were less likely to try to exploit his side of the field and he logged 11 tackles, 18 clearances and nine interceptions.

Starting Predicition

For my money, I feel that Thorhallsson performed well enough over the second half of the season to project that he will be the starting right back for the first game this year, and frankly, it might be so cold in Victoria, BC that Thorhallsson’s icy roots are welcomed. While Halliday has certainly been more of a natural defender, Thorhallsson elevated the Orlando attack in a way that we had not seen since Ruan was doing Ruan things. The main difference is that when Thorhallsson sent in a cross, there was a better chance of it finding someone in purple. Halliday certainly has the chance to push Thorhallsson in training camp, which will only benefit both players’ developmental tracks, but personally I feel that if the Icelandic international was able to step into a new position in the middle of the season last year and contribute the way that he did, then it should be his position to lose, and I would imagine that his ability to defend will only grow with time.


Let us know in the comments below who you think will win the main starting position at right back and let us know if there are any other position battles that you would like broken down before the start of the 2024 season. Vamos Orlando!

Opinion

Orlando City’s Lack of Off-Season Signings Starting to Become a Concern

The Lions’ roster hasn’t gotten any bigger in the last few weeks, so it’s understandable if fans are getting a bit antsy.

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

Three weeks ago I wrote that there was no reason to panic about Orlando City’s lack of off-season signings. It was early in January, and the club typically does a lot of its business throughout the first month of the year. Since then, the club signed Nicolas Rodriguez, but the Lions also traded Mason Stajduhar, and forward Jack Lynn retired. That is more subtraction than addition for a team looking to make it to the next level. Is it now time to panic?

The departure of Stajduhar hits Orlando City supporters in the feels given how long he was with the club, but one may assume the coaches have seen enough from Javier Otero to be confident in his ability to back up Pedro Gallese. The club still needs to bring in another keeper [Editor’s note: this story was written prior to the club signing Carlos Mercado this morning], but Stajduhar’s departure isn’t as big of a problem as it might first seem.

We don’t know how long Duncan McGuire will be unavailable once the season starts. Even if he’s back sooner than expected, Orlando City will still be lacking at the striker position. Ramiro Enrique has proven he can be a starter, but with Jack Lynn’s departure, there isn’t anyone behind him. While Luis Muriel is technically a striker, he tends to play further back in a facilitator role rather than as an actual No. 9. We haven’t seen any transfer moves for a new striker.

The Lions got a big influx of cash, thanks to the Facundo Torres deal. Replacing the goal production of Orlando City’s all-time leading goal scorer is a priority. So far, the club has brought in Rodriguez as an MLS U22 Initiative player. Despite the similarities between the two, Rodriguez is not a replacement for Torres. It is unrealistic to expect the young man to score double-digit goals his first year in MLS.

I’m not even worried about the attacking midfield. As I mentioned above, Muriel is best as a facilitator, Martin Ojeda is now wearing the No. 10 jersey, and Ivan Angulo can play on either side. It’s Torres’ goal contributions I’m worried about missing. Orlando City needs to replace that production sooner rather than later or another slow start seems certain.

I’m not going to address the Wilder Cartagena injury until we know more, but that is also potentially very bad news. That brings us to today. The team is already deep into its preseason trip to Mexico. This is the trip that in the past has been the time when the team truly bonds. Any players brought in at this point will obviously miss that valuable time.

Additionally, unless a signing is someone who has already played in MLS — which is incredibly rare for this front office — it is going to take them time to adapt to the league as well as the club and their new teammates. That brings us back to the real potential for another slow start to the season.

When you have roster turnover, the idea is to bring in players that are better than the players that departed. We know that the ownership is serious about winning. The 2022 Open Cup victory and the Orlando Pride’s two 2024 trophies are a testament to that. Now, it’s time to see that commitment with some substantial signings for City. In some ways, I feel the club has left it a little late, but I’ll take what I can get at this point.

I’m not saying it’s time to panic — though I won’t tell you not to do so — but I’m definitely getting a bit concerned. Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.

Continue Reading

Opinion

Orlando City Needs a Strong Start from its Defense

The defense will need to come together quickly in 2025 for Orlando City to avoid another slow start to the season.

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando City SC / Mark Thor

The opening day of the 2025 Major League Soccer season is less than 30 days, and Orlando City is preparing for the opener against Philadelphia. With a full slate of preseason matches that recently dropped, the 2025 Lions will soon take to the field to put the final touches on preparing various tactics for the season ahead. That starts today with a friendly against Atletico Mineiro.

While there are numerous questions regarding the offensive side of the pitch for Orlando City, the defense should be an area of strength for OCSC as the season begins, and it may need to be, as any new attacking pieces brought in this late in the off-season will need time to settle in.

Starting with the dynamic duo of Cesar Araujo and Wilder Cartagena, Orlando once again will have the good fortune of fielding one of the best defensive midfield pairings in all of MLS. While both Araujo and Cartagena are technically sound and strong defenders on their own, there is a noticeable difference in overall team defense when they both play together. Araujo, who has recently been the target of transfer speculation, is now expected to be locked into Orlando City purple for the upcoming season. He and Cartagena have demonstrated a great ability to take opposing star players out of the game plan, and there is little question regarding their importance when it comes to the successful start of the season.

Moving back toward the goal, Orlando City also returns a complete back line consisting of captain Robin Jansson, Rafael Santos, Dagur Dan Thorhallsson, and either David Brekalo or Rodrigo Schlegel. The tactics employed by Head Coach Oscar Pareja call for the fullbacks to get into the offensive flow as often as the game allows, and both Thorhallsson and Santos have shown that they are capable of attacking. While that part of their game is a bonus, their ability to get back and defend — especially against the counter — will be an early skill to watch as the season begins.

At this point in his career, there will be very few surprises from Jansson, as fans and the coaching staff know exactly what type of effort to expect out of the center back. The only piece of the back line puzzle that will be interesting to watch throughout the early part of the season will be who earns the right to slot in next to Jansson. Due to injury and international duty a season ago, Schlegel wound up winning the starting role from the newly acquired Brekalo. My gut instinct tells me that with an off-season of preparation, we will likely see the younger and more athletic Brekalo get the nod to start the year, with Schlegel the primary backup for both starting center back positions.

Finally, the man who anchors it all, goalkeeper Pedro Gallese, will have the benefit of familiarity when it comes to the defenders in front of him. Gallese ended the 2024 season on a hot streak, in great form, showing his quality in the second half of the season and the playoffs, stopping multiple penalty kicks. He tied for fifth place among all goalkeepers with eight clean sheets in 2024 and will undoubtedly look to add to his career club record as the 2025 season begins.


With all of the defensive starters from the 2024 season back for 2025, Orlando City’s defense is expected to be the cornerstone of early season matches while the offense sorts itself out. The success then, especially during those first few matches, will likely live or die on the shoulders of the back seven defensive players.

Do you expect any cracks in the Orlando City defense to start the year or are you feeling confident in their ability to handle the new attacking pieces that have been added to the Eastern Conference? Let us know in the comments below and as always, vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Opinion

Three Orlando Pride Games to Circle on the Calendar

Let’s take a brief look at three games to pay extra attention to during Orlando’s upcoming NWSL campaign.

Published

on

Image courtesy of Orlando Pride

We got the release of the Orlando Pride’s 2025 schedule on Wednesday, which means we’re that little bit closer to the start of the season on March 7. The nature of the 14-team National Women’s Soccer League means that there are fewer scheduling quirks than with the 30-team Major League Soccer, with each team playing the other 13 clubs twice each. Still, there’s plenty to dig into with regards to how the scheduling shakes out, and now that I’ve had time to examine what 2025 holds, I’ve got three games in particular that I’ve got circled on my match calendar. Behold.

March 7 — vs. Washington Spirit

You had to know this was coming, right? There’s so much to like about this game. Not only is it the home opener, but as the NWSL Challenge Cup match, it’s also a chance to win another piece of silverware in a rematch of last year’s NWSL Championship game. This game sells itself on just about every level imaginable. The Pride return almost everyone from a wildly successful 2024 season, and while there aren’t a ton of new signings to familiarize ourselves with, getting healthy versions of Grace Chanda and Simone Charley is essentially like getting two brand new players. It’ll be our first chance to gauge where the Pride stand as they try to continue on from the high standards that were set last year, and we should also get a couple new banners hoisted into the rafters. You can hardly ask for more than all that.

Aug. 16 — at Kansas City Current

The Current were excellent in 2024, finishing fourth and boasting the league’s best attack, with 57 goals scored in 26 games, for an over two goals per game average. The Pride, meanwhile, had the league’s third-best attack, with 46 goals, and the joint-best defense with just 20 conceded. Orlando never lost to Kansas City in 2024, as the Pride drew and won the regular-season contests and then won again in the semifinal matchup between the two teams. The pair have made a habit of putting on entertaining affairs, and with the match placed as one of the first ones to occur after the league’s July break, it might go a long way towards setting the tone for the back half of Orlando’s season.

Nov. 2 — vs. Seattle Reign

The NWSL is bringing back Decision Day this year, and the Pride have been blessed with a home game on the league’s final day of regular-season play. On paper, Orlando has also been handed a favorable matchup against a Seattle team that struggled last year and is in the midst of a rebuild. Given how tight the margins tend to be in the upper reaches of the league, every point takes on added importance, and playoff scenarios can swing wildly when everyone is playing at the same time. It’s always nice to be able to play at home in a situation that variable, and it can make for a truly memorable atmosphere that will (hopefully) set Orlando up for another postseason run on the right note.


It feels a little cheap to highlight the first and last games of the season, but I can’t help liking what I like. Are there any games that you’re especially looking forward to this season? Be sure to have your say down in the comments. Vamos Orlando!

Continue Reading

Trending