Welcome to your match thread for a Wednesday night U.S. Open Cup semifinal matchup between Orlando City and the Columbus Crew at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field (7:30 p.m., CBS Sports Network, Paramount+). This is the second meeting between the two Eastern Conference rivals this season and the second time the clubs have met in U.S. Open Cup competition in series history. The Lions and Crew are scheduled to meet once more in the regular season in Orlando on Oct. 10.

Here’s what you need to know about the match.

History

The Lions are 10-8-6 in the all-time, regular-season series and 3-5-3 on the road in MLS play. Orlando City is 11-9-6 overall against the Crew in all competitions, which includes a home loss in the playoffs and a home win in the U.S. Open Cup.

The last time these teams met was early this season, a 1-1 draw in Columbus on April 12. It looked like Marco Pasalic’s early goal would stand up until Lion killer Diego Rossi struck with 10 minutes remaining in normal time. Orlando City earned its first road point of the season that night and its first away point under interim head coach Martin Perelman.

In last year’s series, Orlando City hosted Columbus on Oct. 4, 2025, at Inter&Co Stadium. The Crew struck just past the half-hour mark through Andres Herrera, but Pasalic slammed home the rebound of a Luis Muriel shot two minutes later. That was all the scoring in a wasteful 1-1 draw for Orlando. The first meeting of 2025 took place July 25 in Columbus just prior to the Leagues Cup break. The Crew took the lead on Rossi’s spot kick shortly after the hour mark after Pasalic was called for a handball in the box. Ramiro Enrique struck 10 minutes later and again three minutes after that to turn the game around. Martin Ojeda added an insurance goal in stoppage time as the Lions won 3-1.

The two sides faced each other in Columbus on Sept. 21, 2024 in a wild back-and-forth game, with the Crew winning 4-3. Rossi, Christian Ramirez, and Cucho Hernandez staked Columbus to a comfortable 3-0 lead by the 71st minute, and the game seemed over. But Enrique’s goal three minutes after Hernandez scored sparked the Lions, who added a Muriel penalty goal to make it a match again. Miscommunication and a poor back pass from Felipe led to a turnover that allowed Aziel Jackson to score in transition, making it 4-2. Muriel scored late in stoppage time, but the Lions ran out of clock and couldn’t complete the comeback.

The teams opened the 2024 season series against each other on May 25. As has been the case with so many matches between Orlando and Columbus over the years, there was controversy in the Crew’s 2-0 win in Orlando. The opening goal came in the second half on a penalty kick that was awarded upon video review following a penalty call at the other end of the pitch. Referee Jair Marrufo awarded the Lions a penalty for a foul on Steven Moreira against Muriel in the box late in the first half. Before Orlando could take the spot kick, Marrufo went to the monitor and ignored a blatant foul by Rossi in the buildup, ruling it a different attacking phase, despite the Lions never regaining clear control of the ball before the next attack, in which the referee ruled a routine shirt pull by Cesar Araujo — embellished significantly by Aidan Morris falling away from the direction of the tug — was clear-cut enough to wipe out the penalty seconds later at the other end. Rossi converted the penalty in first-half stoppage time, adding a second goal just past the hour mark.

The meeting between the teams with the biggest stakes came in the 2023 MLS Eastern Conference semifinals on Nov. 25, 2023. The teams played scoreless through the 90 minutes plus injury time, with Orlando City defender Rodrigo Schlegel getting sent off late with a second yellow card. The Crew were able to bundle home a goal in extra time and add an insurance marker for a 2-0 win en route to an eventual MLS Cup championship. Ramirez and Hernandez scored for the Crew.

The teams played a memorable game at Exploria Stadium on Sept. 16, 2023, with Orlando coming from behind to snatch a stunning 4-3 victory at the death. Julian Gressel gave Columbus an early lead that held up through the first half. Ojeda equalized just after the restart, but Rossi and Hernandez staked the Crew to a two-goal lead. Facundo Torres pulled one back and Enrique bagged his first MLS brace, with a goal just a few minutes from the end of normal time and another late in stoppage.

The teams met in Columbus on May 13, 2023, playing to a 2-2 draw. Orlando City fell behind 2-0 by halftime on goals by Darlington Nagbe and Jacen Russell-Rowe, but Ercan Kara pulled one back just a few minutes after the restart, and Duncan McGuire leveled the game in stoppage time.

The sides faced each other in Orlando on Decision Day 2022, with City erasing a 1-0 deficit from a Derrick Etienne Jr. goal to win 2-1 and clinch a playoff spot. Junior Urso leveled the game in the second half and Torres struck from the penalty spot late. The meeting in Columbus that year took place on April 16, 2022, with the Lions winning 2-0 on goals by Schlegel and Kara.

The 2021 season series concluded on Oct. 27 in Columbus with the Crew winning 3-2. Columbus had lost five straight to Orlando prior to Lucas Zelarayan’s one-goal, two-assist performance. Miguel Berry and Etienne also scored for the Crew. Daryl Dike pulled a goal back from the spot and Robin Jansson struck late, but it wasn’t enough.

The teams met at Exploria Stadium on Sept. 4, 2021, with the Lions winning 3-2. Orlando built a 2-0 lead on goals by Dike and Silvester van der Water, but a bizarre own goal by Antonio Carlos threw the Crew a lifeline, and a Berry equalizer turned the game around. Urso provided a nice game winner in the 69th minute.

City won the only meeting of the 2020 pandemic season when the 10-man Lions got a late Benji Michel goal to defeat the Crew 2-1 on Nov. 4. Chris Mueller gave Orlando the lead, but Harrison Afful was able to equalize just moments after referee Ramy Touchan sent off Nani on a ludicrous call that was overturned by the MLS independent panel a few days later. Thanks to Michel’s goal, the officiating error didn’t end up costing the Lions, who clinched their first-ever MLS playoff spot with the win.

The Lions swept the season series in 2019, defeating the Crew 1-0 on July 13, 2019, and two weeks previously getting their first road win in the series, 2-0.

Orlando won 2-1 on Oct. 21, 2018 to start a five-game winning streak against the Crew on a pair of penalty kick goals. Yoshimar Yotún and Sacha Kljestan provided the spot kicks to offset Federico Higuain’s opening goal.

The last Crew win in the series prior to the Orlando winning streak was assisted by a horror call by Silviu Petrescu in the 88th minute on July 21, 2018, giving Columbus an equalizer from the penalty spot. Wil Trapp then scored the kind of goal in stoppage time that he’ll probably never score again to lift the Crew to a 3-2 victory in a game the Lions had stolen away from them on a call that Petrescu’s own organization said was an error.

Columbus got the better of Orlando in 2017, going 2-0-1. The Lions were 0-1-1 against Columbus in 2016 and 1-1-1 in the series in 2015, with a home U.S. Open Cup win that season against the Crew as well.

Overview

Orlando City enters tonight on its best streak of the season, having won three consecutive games and going unbeaten in its last five (4-0-1). That includes Saturday’s 3-0 home win over Toronto FC. Antoine Griezmann scored in his fifth straight match to open the scoring, with Harvey Sarajian and Ivan Angulo providing some late breathing room.

The Lions got to this game before the World Cup break with narrow wins on the road against FC Naples (1-0 on April 15) and a heavily rotated New England Revolution side (4-3 on April 29). Orlando City finally hosted a game in the competition in the quarterfinals, crushing Atlanta United 4-1 on May 19. Tiago and Griffin Dorsey are Orlando City’s leading goal scorers in this year’s tournament with two goals apiece. The Lions have also gotten one goal each from Tyrese Spicer and Justin Ellis, along with less likely candidates Iago, Zakaria Taifi, and David Brekalo.

Orlando is 3-7-2 on the road in MLS play and 5-7-2 away in all competitions (6-7-2 if you count the win over Monterrey in Leagues Cup that was played in Inter.co Stadium although the Lions were designated as the road team).

Columbus enters tonight on the heels of a pair of narrow, one-goal defeats, including Saturday’s 1-0 loss at home to the New York Red Bulls. The Crew were last in the Eastern Conference not long ago but have played more competitively since the restart after the World Cup break. That includes reaching the knockout stages in Leagues Cup and climbing a couple of places in the MLS table. The Crew opened their U.S. Open Cup campaign with a 3-0 road win over the Richmond Kickers of USL League One on April 15 before returning home and clobbering One Knoxville SC — also of USL League One — 4-1 on April 29. Competition for Columbus got tougher in the quarterfinal round with the Crew edging New York City FC 1-0 at home on May 20.

Hugo Picard, currently on loan with Troyes in France’s Ligue 1, leads Columbus in scoring in this competition with three goals. Jamal Thiare and Homegrown Chase Adams have a goal apiece, as do former Crew players Daniel Gazdag (now with New England) and Max Arfsten (now with Middlesbrough in England).

The Crew are 5-6-2 in league play in 2026 and 9-6-3 at home in all competitions.

For Orlando to get a result and advance to the semifinals, it must figure out ways to stop leaking goals on the road. The Lions have conceded eight times in their last three away matches. Perelman was able to get Robin Jansson and Dorsey a full game of rest on Saturday, while left back Bernardo Rhein entered in the second half and Brekalo exited early. That freshness could be the difference.

---

Projected Lineups:

Orlando City (4-4-2)

Goalkeeper: Maxime Crepeau.

Defenders: Bernardo Rhein, Robin Jansson, David Brekalo, Griffin Dorsey.

Midfielders: Ivan Angulo, Eduard Atuesta, Joran Gerbet, Justin Ellis.

Forwards: Martin Ojeda, Antoine Griezmann.

Columbus Crew (4-4-2)

Goalkeeper: Patrick Schulte.

Defenders: Brooks Lennon, Malte Amundsen, Sean Zawadski, Steven Moreira.

Midfielders: Lautaro Giaccone, Tarun Karumanchi, Dylan Chambost, Mohamed Farsi.

Forwards: Brais Mendez, Santiago Rodriguez.

How to Watch

Match Time: 7:30 p.m.

Venue: Scotts Miracle-Gro Field — Columbus, OH.

TV/Streaming: CBS Sports Network, Paramount+.

Social Media: For rapid reaction and live updates, follow us on Bluesky Social at @themaneland.bsky.social or follow Orlando City’s official Twitter (@OrlandoCitySC) or Bluesky (@OrlandoCitySC) feed.

---

Enjoy the match. Go City!